Repository navigation
"create an event" does not work with required members #600
Description
In particular as defined today step 3
Let defaultEventInitDict be the result of converting the JavaScript value undefined to the dictionary type accepted by eventInterface’s constructor. (This dictionary type will either be EventInit or a dictionary that inherits from it.)
would throw, which is a problem as https://searchfox.org/mozilla-central/search?q=required&path=Event.webidl suggests there's various events out there that have a required dictionary member.
We can deal with it failing, but that does seem to suggest that if you have a required dictionary member, you need to supply defaults in some other way than IDL. Alternatively we need to allow passing these members in some way to "fire an event" et al which would be the second refactoring to that whole operation within a rather sad short time period.
Activity
marcoscaceres commentedon Aug 27, 2018
Why not let "create an event" just take a dictionary override:
And then change:
So then it just use the passes dictionary?
annevk commentedon Aug 27, 2018
That would probably work, but then you can't use "fire an event" for those events. And if we wanted to enable that, which would make sense, we'd have to redefine how the IDL attributes are initialized and refactor all callers.
(Multiple optional arguments also gets a little ugly and might warrant some refactoring of the callers.)