Candi's Reviews > Voices from Chernobyl: The Oral History of a Nuclear Disaster
Voices from Chernobyl: The Oral History of a Nuclear Disaster
by
by
"Chernobyl is like the war of all wars. There’s nowhere to hide. Not underground, not underwater, not in the air."
While cheerful carols played, holiday lights sparkled, and countless dollars were being spent on mostly unnecessary gadgets and superfluous luxuries, I read this account of one of the worst disasters ever to afflict our planet. I sunk further into the funk that threatened the existence of my Christmas tree and that brought my own holiday shopping to a screeching halt. It seemed absurd to parade around with bags in hand while the voices of the survivors of the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear power plant explosion echoed incessantly within my head.
Svetlana Alexievich, Ukrainian journalist and winner of the 2015 Nobel Prize in Literature, has compiled a most remarkable narrative of the catastrophe from the people who witnessed the horror firsthand. Moms, dads, wives, husbands, children, scientists, liquidators, politicians, and even refugees to the area were interviewed and asked to speak candidly. The stories are full of sorrow, shock, bewilderment, anger, and occasionally stoical humor. All were straightforward and unembellished. I sensed that each carried the weight of genuine feeling.
I can’t write anything more meaningful than what the sufferers themselves have already said. Please listen to their voices:
"I killed her. I. She. Saved. My little girl saved me, she took the whole radioactive shock into herself, she was like the lightning rod for it. She was so small."
"The future is destroying me, not the past."
"You’re a normal person! And then one day you’re suddenly turned into a Chernobyl person. Into an animal, something that everyone’s interested in, and that no one knows anything about. You want to be like everyone else, and now you can’t."
"I want to bear witness: my daughter died from Chernobyl. And they want us to forget about it."
"I suddenly started wondering about what’s better—to remember or to forget?"
"If we’d beaten Chernobyl, people would talk about it and write about it more. Or if we’d understood Chernobyl. But we don’t know how to capture any meaning from it. We’re not capable of it. We can’t place it in our human experience or our human time-frame."
"We’re all—peddlers of the apocalypse. Big and small. I have these images in my mind, these pictures."
"There are ten million Belarussians, and two million of us live on poisoned land. It’s a huge devil’s laboratory."
"This level of lying, this incredible level, with which Chernobyl is connected in our minds, was comparable only to the level of lies during the big war."
"Chernobyl is the catastrophe of the Russian mind-set… it wasn’t just the reactor that exploded, but an entire system of values."
"The kids draw Chernobyl. The trees in the pictures grow upside-down. The water in the rivers is red or yellow. They’ll draw it and then cry."
"… everyone was raised to think that the peaceful Soviet atom was as safe as peat or coal. We were people chained by fear and prejudices. We had the superstition of our faith."
"I used to write poems. I was in love with a girl. In fifth grade. In seventh grade I found out about death."
It’s not difficult to be shocked by the statistics of the disaster. You can look those up anywhere and your jaw will drop. But to understand what ordinary people like me and you went through is absolutely heart-rending. Reading their words, commiserating with their feelings of misery and fear, and knowing that the suffering for many of these people still continues – that is what makes this so impactful. Naturally, I began to think “What if…” But that’s just too painful to ponder any further right now. When I’m feeling braver, I will watch the miniseries I’ve heard so much about. I suspect it will be more frightening than any Stephen King adaptation could ever be.
"What should I tell you? Death is the fairest thing in the world. No one’s ever gotten out of it. The earth takes everyone—the kind, the cruel, the sinners. Aside from that, there’s no fairness on earth."
While cheerful carols played, holiday lights sparkled, and countless dollars were being spent on mostly unnecessary gadgets and superfluous luxuries, I read this account of one of the worst disasters ever to afflict our planet. I sunk further into the funk that threatened the existence of my Christmas tree and that brought my own holiday shopping to a screeching halt. It seemed absurd to parade around with bags in hand while the voices of the survivors of the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear power plant explosion echoed incessantly within my head.
Svetlana Alexievich, Ukrainian journalist and winner of the 2015 Nobel Prize in Literature, has compiled a most remarkable narrative of the catastrophe from the people who witnessed the horror firsthand. Moms, dads, wives, husbands, children, scientists, liquidators, politicians, and even refugees to the area were interviewed and asked to speak candidly. The stories are full of sorrow, shock, bewilderment, anger, and occasionally stoical humor. All were straightforward and unembellished. I sensed that each carried the weight of genuine feeling.
I can’t write anything more meaningful than what the sufferers themselves have already said. Please listen to their voices:
"I killed her. I. She. Saved. My little girl saved me, she took the whole radioactive shock into herself, she was like the lightning rod for it. She was so small."
"The future is destroying me, not the past."
"You’re a normal person! And then one day you’re suddenly turned into a Chernobyl person. Into an animal, something that everyone’s interested in, and that no one knows anything about. You want to be like everyone else, and now you can’t."
"I want to bear witness: my daughter died from Chernobyl. And they want us to forget about it."
"I suddenly started wondering about what’s better—to remember or to forget?"
"If we’d beaten Chernobyl, people would talk about it and write about it more. Or if we’d understood Chernobyl. But we don’t know how to capture any meaning from it. We’re not capable of it. We can’t place it in our human experience or our human time-frame."
"We’re all—peddlers of the apocalypse. Big and small. I have these images in my mind, these pictures."
"There are ten million Belarussians, and two million of us live on poisoned land. It’s a huge devil’s laboratory."
"This level of lying, this incredible level, with which Chernobyl is connected in our minds, was comparable only to the level of lies during the big war."
"Chernobyl is the catastrophe of the Russian mind-set… it wasn’t just the reactor that exploded, but an entire system of values."
"The kids draw Chernobyl. The trees in the pictures grow upside-down. The water in the rivers is red or yellow. They’ll draw it and then cry."
"… everyone was raised to think that the peaceful Soviet atom was as safe as peat or coal. We were people chained by fear and prejudices. We had the superstition of our faith."
"I used to write poems. I was in love with a girl. In fifth grade. In seventh grade I found out about death."
It’s not difficult to be shocked by the statistics of the disaster. You can look those up anywhere and your jaw will drop. But to understand what ordinary people like me and you went through is absolutely heart-rending. Reading their words, commiserating with their feelings of misery and fear, and knowing that the suffering for many of these people still continues – that is what makes this so impactful. Naturally, I began to think “What if…” But that’s just too painful to ponder any further right now. When I’m feeling braver, I will watch the miniseries I’ve heard so much about. I suspect it will be more frightening than any Stephen King adaptation could ever be.
"What should I tell you? Death is the fairest thing in the world. No one’s ever gotten out of it. The earth takes everyone—the kind, the cruel, the sinners. Aside from that, there’s no fairness on earth."
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Voices from Chernobyl.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 17, 2016
– Shelved as:
to-read
February 17, 2016
– Shelved
February 17, 2016
– Shelved as:
non-fiction
February 17, 2016
– Shelved as:
history
February 17, 2016
– Shelved as:
science-math-technology
December 1, 2019
–
Started Reading
December 18, 2019
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 69 (69 new)
message 1:
by
Beata
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Dec 02, 2019 06:15PM
reply
|
flag
I can see that is the case already, Beata! Wow! Not exactly the most festive book for the holiday season, but one that I'm very interested in reading.
I recently read Midnight in Chernobyl: The Untold Story of the World's Greatest Nuclear Disaster; this book sounds like an even more harrowing and difficult book to read, to read the survivors own words. It boggles the mind, learning about this disaster, the extent of needless suffering. I hope you will find the miniseries worthwhile and well-done when you feel up to watching it.
Thank you very much, Jenna! I cut back considerably this year, and I admire your decision to refrain from the madness completely! I aim to cut back even more next year.
I'd like to read the other Chernobyl book you've mentioned and gain even more perspective. The miniseries does look like it will be excellent :)
It truly is tragic, Tatevik. So many lives lost due to poor choices and secrecy.
Thanks so much, Paula. I love the high praise for the miniseries! I'm going to try to watch it very soon.
Sara, it was difficult to decide which quotes to share! Each story is so important. And you are right, this could happen to anyone at anytime. You just never know. I hope that someday you will get a chance to read this. I think it will be just as impactful to you as it was to me. But you need to be in the right frame of mind to tackle it, so don't rush!
Thank you, Julie! Not an easy read by any means. Best read when you don't mind feeling all mopey afterwards!
Thanks, Sue! Wow, that's a long hold. For some reason, I was able to get it right away. Can't wait to hear your thoughts on it when your turn comes up in the queue. :)
Thank you, Jonny. You are quite right. It's the human element that really gets me to sit up and really pay attention.
Thanks so much, Jan. This was quite an eye-opener for me. Makes you stop and consider the important things :)
Thanks very much, Mark. I've got the miniseries lined up for when I've recovered a bit from the read :)
Thank you, Tammy. Gosh it was a tough one!
Bravo, my friend!😀
Kathleen, I've put off reading this book for quite some time. I knew I wanted to read it, but it was a matter of timing. If one of my groups hadn't been reading it last month, I probably would have delayed even longer! I'm glad I read it. As you say, it's necessary for us to really grasp what these kind of events meant to the people directly affected in order for it to seem more personal and impactful. Thank you for kind comment :)
Many thanks, Richard! This is a book I won't soon forget. In fact, I believe many of the accounts will be imprinted permanently in my mind.
P.S. I know there is a (Apparently really good) show on HBO about it but haven’t watched yet. I might do one day...
Thank you, Rita! Yes, this is a book you have to sort of mentally prepare yourself for. Know that it will be heartbreaking. I'm glad that people finally felt like they could speak about this tragedy, because it's one that we should all be talking about.
Thank you, Holly! I can imagine that seeing the images on the screen will really make this even more horrific.
Thanks a bunch, Lori. There are so many heartbreaking stories. I'm glad that you appreciated the quotes, despite the sadness :)
Thanks very much, ZT. Always appreciate your kind comments :)
Wyndy, I know, it's certainly painful to read about. Thank you for reading my thoughts on it! :)
Thank you very much, Libby. Isn't it incredible?! How does this hapoen?! And some people moved to the area after the event because it was a better alternative to their old life!
Thank you, Michael. She is well deserving of the Prize. I am looking forward to reading more of her work and am currently hunting them down to add to my own library.