Steven Godin's Reviews > Chernobyl Prayer

Chernobyl Prayer by Svetlana Alexievich
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26706841
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: russia-ukraine, non-fiction, nobel-laureates, history


"Sometime in the future, we will understand Chernobyl as a philosophy. Two states divided by barbed wire: one, the zone itself; the other, everywhere else. People have hung white towels on the rotting stakes around the zone, as if they were crucifixes. It's a custom here. People go there as if to a graveyard. A post-technological world. Time has gone backwards. What is buried there is not only their home but a whole epoch. An epoch of faith. In science! In an ideal of social justice! A great empire came apart at the seems, collapsed. First Afghanistan, then Chernobyl. When the empire disintegrated, we were on our own. I hesitate to say it, but...we love Chernobyl. We have come to love it. It is the meaning of our lives, which we have found again, the meaning of our suffering. Like the war. The world heard about us Belarusians after Chernobyl. It was our introduction to Europe"

Chairwoman, Woman's committee of Children of Chernobyl.



My own memories of April 26 1986 and the Chernobyl catastrophe I remember my parents being glued to the TV on that day. I was nine-years-old at the time, and even though I didn't fully understand what was going on, I knew it was bad; really bad.
Over time, my knowledge of the disaster remained sketchy, picking up bits of information here and there, but it felt to me like the whole event was brushed under the carpet, for the rest of the world to forget, no outside eyes getting on to what really happened in the clean up operation.
Until now, and reading Alexievich's book, the only image that was strong in my mind is of the abandoned bumper cars from the visiting fair, rotting away in a mechanical graveyard.
That's now all changed.

Whatever her genre, Svetlana Alexievich is an original, a true voice, a voice that is hers and hers alone, but it's through the voice of others, the ones the rest of the world never got to here, opening up on their thoughts, living smack bang in the middle of the worse possible nightmare. Exploring pain and loss on an unprecedented scale, the forgotten speak out, making for one of the most upsetting, harrowing and heart-felt books I will ever get to read. If there is a light at the end of the tunnel, it's no more than a pinprick to the naked eye, this is writing of immense suffering, of death, the soul of mankind rocked to it's core. But it is also filled with a gigantic love, an all powerful love that no amount of radiation could ever destroy, as these people show what big hearts us humans carry around with us. Some of the accounts within, I just couldn't quite believe, that had me seeing red. Surely this is some sort of joke?, how the hell could these things be aloud to happen?, this was 1986, not 1896, the bodies in control (or should that be no control what so ever) should hang their heads in shame!. The amount of deaths and deformities that should never have been allowed to happen makes me sick to the stomach. Some were unavoidable. Most weren't.

A true history of its people need be no more than the howls of despair of millions of souls. Punctuated by moments of incredible tenderness, courage and grim humour. The scale of the devastation and its insidious nature are perhaps beyond the power of the individual mind to imagine, which is one good reason why the polyphonic form Alexievich has made her own is so unique and so appropriate. Only the voice of the witnesses can do the events justice, and in Chernobyl Prayer, after some shocking facts about the explosion and its immediate aftermath, it's the testimony of those living close by, that grab you around the neck, before dragging you off into their world.

Alexievich’s documentary approach makes the experiences vivid, sometimes almost unbearably so, but it’s a remarkably democratic way of constructing a book, and Svetlana Alexievich fully deserved the Nobel Prize for her work: it's that important. A non-fiction masterpiece.
153 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Chernobyl Prayer.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 10, 2018 – Shelved
February 12, 2018 – Started Reading
February 13, 2018 –
page 61
20.75% "So, my love, have you understood my sadness? Pass it on to the people, though I might not be around then. They'll find me in the earth. Under the roots."
February 16, 2018 –
page 127
43.2% "So far, she hasn't understood, but one day she'll ask us why she's different from the others. Why no man will be able to love her. I wanted...I needed
to prove...that...I wanted to get documents so she'd grow up and find out it wasn't me and my husband to blame. It wasn't our love."
February 20, 2018 –
page 238
80.95% "Chernobyl filled my life and my heart grew bigger...but it aches. It's like a secret key. After suffering great pain, you talk, you find you speak well.
I did...I only found that language when I really loved. And now. If I didn't
believe he's in heaven, how could I have survived that?."
February 21, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Great review, Steven!


Steven Godin Diane wrote: "Great review, Steven!"

Thanks, Diane.


Lisa Excellent review, Steven! I was about the same age as you when it happened, and remember it as oneof the first times the grown-up worries beame real for me as well. Glued to the television is quite right! It took another three years until that happened again in the same way: Fall of the Berlin Wall. And then 9/11, but I was at uni then...


message 4: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse The way in which she gives a voice to such a multitude of voices, and the effect of that polyphonic form dealing with such harrowing facts of history left me in awe for Alexievich when reading Secondhand Times, Steven. You captured her skill and the effects of her writing on the reader excellently. Sadly the strongest political party in our government seems to have forgotten Chernobyl, endlessly extending the lifetimes of the three oldest reactors and trying to sabotage the phase-out legislation.


Steven Godin Ilse wrote: "The way in which she gives a voice to such a multitude of voices, and the effect of that polyphonic form dealing with such harrowing facts of history left me in awe for Alexievich when reading Seco..."

It's scary to think of the possibilities IIse, even after many years. You can't rule out future problems. Worryingly, worse than before. Extending older reactors is madness!. The fallout doesn't bare thinking of.

And I will have to read 'Secondhand Times', thanks for bringing that up.


Steven Godin Lisa wrote: "Excellent review, Steven! I was about the same age as you when it happened, and remember it as oneof the first times the grown-up worries beame real for me as well. Glued to the television is quite..."

Thanks Lisa, this was the first biggest news story of my life time.
And what I learnt here made me both sad. And angry of the authorities, what clowns!. sending workers in with little or no protection. "Oh, yes, we will pay you double the amount of roubles, and throw in a new car to boot". What good is that? when you are coughing up chunks of your own lungs.


message 7: by Ruben (new)

Ruben Don't think I could bring myself to read this. Great write-up though, Steven.


Steven Godin Rubin wrote: "Don't think I could bring myself to read this. Great write-up though, Steven."

Thanks, Rubin. It's a tough read, yes, but an important one.


message 9: by Caterina (new) - added it

Caterina Stunning introduction (for me) to the work of Svetlana Alexievich and in particular, this. Thank you, Steven. The quotation at the beginning is astonishing, almost as if it must be a joke -- just as you found the events described throughout the book.


Candi An exceptional review, Steven. I must make a point of reading Alexievich soon.


Steven Godin Candi wrote: "An exceptional review, Steven. I must make a point of reading Alexievich soon."

Thank you, Candi.


Steven Godin Caterina wrote: "Stunning introduction (for me) to the work of Svetlana Alexievich and in particular, this. Thank you, Steven. The quotation at the beginning is astonishing, almost as if it must be a joke -- just a..."

It's an eye opener for sure Caterina, a lot of what went on in the aftermath I still can't quite believe.


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Thumwood Wonderful review, Steven. I live in Ukraine and visited Chernobyl and the Chernobyl museum in Kyiv, but as much as I felt I knew , I really understood very little until I read this book. Not an easy read, but so important. And has encouraged me to read more Alexievich soon.


Steven Godin Lisa wrote: "Wonderful review, Steven. I live in Ukraine and visited Chernobyl and the Chernobyl museum in Kyiv, but as much as I felt I knew , I really understood very little until I read this book. Not an eas..."

Thanks Lisa. I will definitely be reading more Alexievich. For me, she has opened a door that is difficult to turn your back on.


message 15: by Cecily (new)

Cecily Thank you for sharing "the howls of despair of millions of souls", painful as it is. And we're barely affected. Things like this need to be remembered and reremembered.


Steven Godin Cecily wrote: "Thank you for sharing "the howls of despair of millions of souls", painful as it is. And we're barely affected. Things like this need to be remembered and reremembered."

Every now and again it just makes sense to read something like this.
When it feels like we're having a bad day, we're not.


message 17: by Czarny (new)

Czarny Pies You are in top form. Congratulations on a review with real stylistic brio.


Steven Godin Czarny wrote: "You are in top form. Congratulations on a review with real stylistic brio."

Thanks, Czarny.


message 19: by Khush (new)

Khush Great review


Steven Godin Khush wrote: "Great review"

Thanks, Khush.


Nasreen Ghori Speechless


back to top