Julie G's Reviews > 84, Charing Cross Road

84, Charing Cross Road by Helene Hanff
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5211606
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: new-york-state-of-mind, 70-from-the-1970s, the-british-invasion, writers-on-writing

Interestingly, I have just read two books in a row for my 1970s reading project that were published in the 1970s, but took place at an earlier time. It feels, to me, a little bit like cheating, but they were popular books in the 70s, regardless, so here I am, reviewing another one (accidentally).

And, fittingly, this non-fiction story, compiled like an epistolary novel, reminded me of a memory I have from the early-mid 1980s, so let me misbehave, for a moment, and cheat on my beloved 70s with another decade.

This book reminded me of a period of time in my life when I was babysitting, every Saturday night, for a gorgeous college professor and her husband (old what's-his-name). I was a young teen, and, after the kids would go to bed, I'd pull a book down from their fabulous home library, put on some soft porn from HBO in the background (this house is the setting for another review of mine: Wise Blood ) and then creep into their kitchen for my one weekly indulgence: an Entenmann's chocolate doughnut.

Back at my own house, my mother was a combination of Twiggy mixed with Jane Fonda and we had fat-free bodies and a sugar-free household for all of the 1970s and 1980s. (And then therapy for the next 20 years).

So. . . around 10pm every Saturday night for about two years, I would defy our household rules (because I wasn't home, duh), and I would take one perfectly formed chocolate doughnut and hold it out before me like the Holy Grail, then place it reverently on one perfectly formed white napkin and appreciate the yin/yang duality of my life before tearing into that treat in the den like a barnyard animal.

The sugar and fat would rush my senses while inappropriate scenes from movies like “Porky's” played on in the background and I would discover my next precious read.

Remembering those Saturday nights fills me with nostalgia. I had no idea I was having that much fun at the time, but I know it now.

Sometimes we don't know how special something is, until it's over. We hope, when we remember, that we have visuals, letters. We hope that someone else remembers, too.
140 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read 84, Charing Cross Road.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 18, 2021 – Shelved
March 26, 2022 – Started Reading
March 26, 2022 –
page 3
2.83% "Will you please translate your prices hereafter? I don't add too well in plain American, I haven't a prayer of ever mastering bilingual arithmetic.
Yours, Helene Hanff"
March 26, 2022 –
page 13
12.26% "Please write and tell me about London. I live for the day when I step off the boat-train and feel its dirty sidewalks under my feet."
March 26, 2022 –
page 61
57.55% "Why is it that people who wouldn't dream of stealing anything else think it's perfectly all right to steal books?"
March 26, 2022 –
page 93
87.74% "Frank and I were so very much opposites, he so kind and gentle and me with my Irish background always fighting for my rights."
March 26, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 62 (62 new)


Tatevik Julie, you need to read this! I am serious!


Kimber This one is on my radar.


Kat (Books are Comfort Food) Glad this was such a wonderful read, Julie. I like your reading project. 🌺🌺🌺


Zoeytron I, for one, loved reading of the memory this sparked within you. Excellent!


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Loved reading your review on this. Excellent Julie 💜


Julie G Tatevik,
I read it! What a delight.


message 7: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan O'Neill "I had no idea I was having that much fun at the time at the time, but I know it now"
I love that! Another great review Julie; a lovely mix of wistfulness and humour. I'm feeling second-hand nostalgia!


Julie G Kimber,
It's a precious tidbit and Ms. Hanff was a funny woman!


message 9: by Jenna (new)

Jenna ❤ ❀  ❤ "we had fat-free bodies and a sugar-free household for all of the 1970s and 1980s. (And then therapy for the next 20 years)." --- You have me cracking up, Julie!!!! 🤣


Jeannie Nice review, Julie. I want one of those chocolate donuts now! lol
I have a copy of this book, I am looking forward to it!


Kimber I love how your reflections relate to a book ! And takes nothing from the book itself.


Lori  Keeton Fantastic memory, Julie! I still need to read this.


Julie G Thank you, Kimber. Any book lover/book collector would find it hard not to be charmed by this true story.


Julie G Thanks, Kat. I never thought I'd be a "reading project" person, but I should have known, since I was frequently coming up with themes that I would present to my book club. It is so much more inspiring to take on reading projects when you know that you have readers for friends who are truly interested in the outcomes.


message 15: by Mark (new) - added it

Mark  Porton Oh my Jools, that last paragraph is moving. Beautifully put. I loved this review, even though you hardly mentioned the thing (the book blurb does sound like it's a wonderful story though) - how can one get a babysitting gig like that? Nice one - I laughed at your 'fat-free' household and then the therapy (I shouldn't laugh at that last bit - but shit it's funny). Great stuff, great review :))


Sherry Such a wonderful review! Weirdly, I had a similar feeling of nostalgia, when I read Virgin Suicides.


message 17: by Char (new)

Char Books which are nostalgic are truly the best kind. This review is really moving, I'm curious (even if i didn't grow up in the 70s haha)


Julie G Thank you, ZT. I'm so grateful for friends like you on here.


Julie G Thanks, Margaret. I think you would adore this book. What a love letter to England!


Julie G Jonathan,
Second hand nostalgia is so much better than second hand smoke, isn't it?


Paula Lovely review!


Kathleen Love your remembrance--brought back some babysitting memories of my own! Like you, I love Helene and this great little book.


Julie G Jenna,
Thank you for always getting my humor!!


message 24: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Vegan Great review/story, Julie.

I’m so depressed. I just went looking for my copy and realized it did not make the cut when I had to give up most of my books. My guess is it was one of the ones that had mold because I don’t think I would’ve given it up otherwise but I’m not sure. I can’t afford to buy any books either so I can’t replace the last ones. At least this time (losing books) it was mostly my choice. Goodreads is getting too depressing for me because of all my missing books though.


message 25: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Vegan Whew! After all that I found it. I didn’t think I’d give it up.


Julie G Jeannie,
A devoted reader like you will just eat this up (maybe along with a good doughnut!).
xoxo


message 27: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Julie your own story is so sad and goddam funny. I hope you eat all the doughnuts you want now ! Hugs !


Julie G Thank you, Kimber. I'm grateful to have friends like you who understand my own personal brand of lunacy!


message 29: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri Julie, your review brought back so many memories of my babysitting years when I was young, and dessert restrictions by (of course) my mother who allowed, perhaps encouraged, my older brother to eat as much as he wanted.


Candi Oh, those babysitting days! We didn't have HBO in our household, so I also indulged in mostly horror flicks when I was lucky enough to land the babysitting gig before my sister :D We were allowed a donut or two now and then at home, but there were plenty of non-food related restrictions to last a lifetime :D I was just sharing a story at work today about a rule that was broken and its ensuing consequences! Thanks for the great review and the memories, Julie :D


Julie G Thanks, Lori. I read it in about an hour and I was positively delighted by it.


Tantravahi God I LOVED this one. I stumbled across it during one of my fits to read a particular genre (books on books for this one) and then I wanted to get my hands on a physically copy (which I couldn't, 'cause I stay in a third world country that is increasingly staying third world). I recently found it! It's so precious. Hear hear to your last paragraph. :')


Julie G Thank you, Mark. After 11 years of reviewing books on here, I am proud to proclaim that I have never been accused of a spoiler alert!


message 34: by Ned (new)

Ned Killed it Julie, i loved and related to your story. Why we read and those memories color the experience.


message 35: by Tiffany (new)

Tiffany Love the flashback. I know exactly what you’re talking about with the E donuts.


message 36: by JanB (new) - rated it 4 stars

JanB I read this a few years back and also found it charming. Lovely review Julie and I loved reading your childhood memory….books, HBO, and donuts….heaven! 💕


message 37: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Now I want a doughnut, and I don't even like doughnuts.


Julie G Hi Sherry,
I loved your review of this book!
I also love that you mentioned that The Virgin Suicides provoked nostalgia for you. It did for me as well, and so did his other novel, Middlesex. (Oh, and by the way, I am madly in love with Jeffrey Eugenides and will run away with him, if he asks--sorry, I digress).

This has me wondering. . . are there certain authors who are better at this than others? I think the answer is probably Yes. Mr. Eugenides does it well, and so does E.B. White. Another great novel for nostalgia is Margaret Atwood's The Blind Assassin.


Julie G Hi Char,
Thank you for your kind words. To be honest--despite this book's publication date, the events within it start almost 20 years before that. Meaning, it's not my time for nostalgia, either, but it still provoked it. Even when she mentions books in her letters that no one is really familiar with anymore, you still understand her. As readers, we can't help but relate to her passion and her requests for certain titles.


Julie G Thank you, Paula.


Julie G Thanks, Kathleen. "Adventures in Babysitting" was a real thing (not just a movie)!


Tatevik Julie wrote: "Tatevik,
I read it! What a delight."


Yey!!!!
It's interesting how a book can remind you of a quite warm memory that is not related at all to the book.


message 43: by Vishakha (new)

Vishakha Julie, loved reading your own flashback and the concluding paragraph. A sugar-free household must be distressing, no wonder you enjoyed the donut with such relish. Love the description - tearing into it like a barnyard animal :D


Angela M Loved this book, your review. My fav was Entenmann’s chocolate cake. My nephew has fond memories of his Dad who always bought Entenmann’s raspberry danish told me that the founder of the company who built it from a family bakery passed away a few weeks ago. He was 92. Your chocolate donut reminded me of that chocolate cake I haven’t had in years .


message 45: by Carol (new)

Carol Julie,
You'll never be accused of revealing spoilers in your reviews. 😂
Your witty and clever reviews are always delightful and make me laugh out loud!


Persephone's Pomegranate Sometimes we don't know how special something is, until it's over. - Nicely said.


message 47: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Aw, what a great review. Sorry diet culture applied at a young age fucked you up. It's a common occurrence, sadly.


message 48: by Robin (new)

Robin I came across the film version of this on Netflix the other day (Anthony Hopkins...) but thought, not yet. I need to read the book first. I'm glad I made that decision, based on your doughnut-dream-nostalgia-trip it inspired!


Julie G Lisa,
I'm pretty sure I'm still grieving the 500 books I gave up last year to move. There should be a name for the sensation of hunting for a book that you "know you have," and then realizing that you don't own it any more.


message 50: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Vegan Julie wrote: "Lisa,
I'm pretty sure I'm still grieving the 500 books I gave up last year to move. There should be a name for the sensation of hunting for a book that you "know you have," and then realizing that ..."


Julie, We should coin a word!!!

I'm sorry you also had to give up books.

I did find my copy of this. Thankfully.

I went (originally, not recently) from 15,000 books (recently maybe 9,000 tops) to only about 1,200. I could see going down to 1,000 if I have to move to a much smaller place but below that I think I'd spiral into a too bad depression.


« previous 1
back to top