Env 1
Env 1
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 1
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 2
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 3
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
INTRODUCTION TO EIA
Emergence of EIA
History of Environmental Assessment in Nepal
Environmental Policy and Regulations in Nepal of GoN
Definition of EIA and Types of EIA
EIA Objectives
EIA Principles
EIA benefits and flaws
Strengths and limitations of EIA
Project cycle and EIA
Screening
Difference between BES, IEE, EIA
Emergence of EIA
The development is carried out to provide services
-to improve quality of life.
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 4
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 5
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 6
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 7
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
EIA in Nepal…..
Progresses were made in the Environmental
protection issue during the 8th five year plan
(1992-1997)
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 8
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
EIA in Nepal……
Development of National Environmental Policies and
Action Plan
Foundation of EPA/EPR
Constitution of Nepal 2047
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 9
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 10
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
EIA Definition
EIA is a process of
Gathering environmental information
Describing a development
Predicting and describing the environmental
effects of the development
Defining ways of avoiding, reducing or
compensating for these effects
Consulting the general public and specific bodies
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 11
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
EIA Definition….
Environmental Impact Assessment is defined as "the
systematic process of identifying future consequences
of a current or proposed action" by the International
association for Impact Assessment".
It is systematic, reproducible and interdisciplinary
assessment for identification, prediction, evaluation,
mitigation and management of impacts from a
proposed development and its reasonable
alternatives.
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 12
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 13
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Types of EIA
Regional EIA
Regional EIA integrates environmental concerns into
development planning for a geographic region,
normally at the sub- country level.
For Example- In a large industrial estate, the
individual industrial emissions may be within
tolerance limits, the cumulative effects of the
emissions can lead to a serious deterioration of the
regional air quality.
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 14
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 15
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Sectoral EIA
Sectoral EIA helps in addressing specific environmental
problems that may be encountered in planning and
implementing sectoral development projects. (Example –
hydro sector, transportation sector)
SEA offers an opportunity for sector-wide environmental
analysis before investment priorities have been
determined.
Once sectoral level development plans have the integrated
sectoral environmental concerns addressed, the scope of
project-level EIA will be quite narrow.
Sectoral EIA will help to address specific environmental
problems that may be encountered in planning and
implementing sectoral development projects.
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 16
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 17
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Screening
Many projects are implemented every year by
government, private sector and public sector.
All of them do not need to go through EA process.
Screening can be defined as preliminary activity
undertaken to classify level of environmental
assessment that requires for given proposals.
There are three levels as per EPA2076/EPR2077 of
Nepal, they are Brief Environmental Study BES,
IEE or EIA.
Objective of Screening
Screening of development proposals during the early
stages of the project planning accomplices the following
objectives and therefore important.
• Saves money
• Saves time
• Inform about need and scale of the project
• Avoid un necessary delays
• Immediately identifies the major environmental
impacts that are likely
• Establishes need for different level of EIA study to be
conducted.
7/28/2023 D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 36
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 18
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 19
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Criteria Project for which Project for which Project for which
impacts and impacts and mitigation impacts and mitigation
mitigation are are known or proven are not known or proven
known or proven
Public Notice In any one local In any one local In any one National
newspaper newspaper daily newspaper and in
website of respected
body.
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 20
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
EPR 2077
Schedule 1
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 21
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Schedule 1
Schedule 2
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 22
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Schedule 2
Schedule 2
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 23
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Schedule 3
Schedule 3
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 24
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Schedule 3
EIA Objectives
Identification of nature and potential of specific significant
environmental issues
Avoid cost and delay in project implementation
Facilitation of an early agreement on continuous issues.
Identification of mitigation measures for significant
environment issues
Identification of mechanism for enhancing beneficial
impacts
Facilitation of decision making to attain sustainable
development
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 25
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Principles of EIA
EIA is based on following eight guiding principles
Participation
Transparency
Certainty
Accountability
Credibility
Cost effectiveness
Flexibility
Practicality
It also includes
Socio economic
Cultural conditions
Biophysical environment
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 26
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 27
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Benefits Flaws
Provides an effective Unavailability for reliable data
mechanism for coordination, (mostly in developing
environmental integration, countries)
negotiations and feed back
Top-level decision making Too focused on scientific
analysis (sometimes)
Triggers an institutional Poor presentation of EIA
building report (bulky volumes,
scientific explanation,
difficult to understand)
Achieve a balance between the Compliance monitoring after
impact of developmental and EIA is seldom carried out
environmental concern
7/28/2023 D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 56
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 28
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 29
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 30
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Project Types
As per EPA/ EPR of Nepal there are three project types
1 Project requiring Brief environmental study
Schedule 1
2 Project requiring Initial environmental examination
Schedule 2
3 Project requiring Environmental impact assessment
Schedule3
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 31
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Types of impacts
• Physical and socio-economic
• Direct, indirect and cumulative
• Short and long run
• Local ,regional and global
• Adverse and beneficial
• Reversible and irreversible
• Quantitative and qualitative
• Distribution by group and/or area
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 32
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Impact significance
Impact significance is not necessarily related to the
impact magnitude.
Sometimes very small impacts, such as the disturbance
of the nest of a pair of endangered birds, may be
significant.
When determining the significance of the potential
impacts of a proposal, all of the above factors should
be taken into consideration.
Some MCQs
1. ………… is the first and simplest tier in project evaluation.
a) Screening b) Scoping
c) Mitigation d) Prediction
2. . Screening criteria for BES study is based on Schedule …..…… of
Rule 3 of EPR 2020?
a) Schedule 1 b) Schedule 2
c) Schedule 3 d) Schedule 4
3. Screening criteria for IEE study is based on Schedule …..……… of Rule 3
of EPR 2020?
a) Schedule 1 b) Schedule 2
c) Schedule 3 d) Schedule 4
4. Screening criteria for EIA study is based on Schedule …..……… of Rule 3
of EPR 2020?
a) Schedule 1 b) Schedule 2
c) Schedule 3 d) Schedule 4
5. Format of ToR for BES is in Schedule………… of EPR 2020.
a) Schedule 5 b) Schedule 6
c) Schedule 7 d) Schedule 8
7/28/2023 D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 66
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 33
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Some MCQs
6. Format of ToR for IEE is in Schedule………… of EPR 2020.
a) Schedule 5 b) Schedule 6
c) Schedule 7 d) Schedule 8
7. Format of ToR for EIA is in Schedule………… of EPR 2020.
a) Schedule 5 b) Schedule 6
c) Schedule 7 d) Schedule 8
8. Format of BES report is in schedule…… of EPR 2020.
a) Schedule 9 b) Schedule 10
c) Schedule 11 d) Schedule 12
9. Format of IEE report is in schedule…… of EPR 2020.
a) Schedule 9 b) Schedule 10
c) Schedule 11 d) Schedule 12
10. Format of EIA report is in schedule…… of EPR 2020.
a) Schedule 9 b) Schedule 10
c) Schedule 11 d) Schedule 12
11. Scoping is required only in ………………
a) BES b) IEE
c) EIA d) all of the above
7/28/2023 D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 67
Some MCQs
12. As per EPA 2076, EIA is ………..
a) Ecological Impact Assessment
b) Environmental Impact Audit
c) Environmental Impact Area
d) Environmental Impact Assessment
13. ToR means…….
a) Total output Report b) Terms of Reference
c) Terms of Report d) The onion Router
14. As per EPA 2076, BES means ………
a) Brief Examination Study
b) Broad Examination Study
c) Beginning Environmental Study
d) Brief Environmental Study
15.As per EPA 2019 (EPA 2076), Ministry means ………
a) Ministry of Forest and Environment (MoFE)
b) Ministry of Energy, Water Resources and Irrigation (MoEWRI)
c) Ministry of Health and Population (MoHP)
d) Ministry of Water Supply (MoWS)
16. For public notice of EIA the notice should be published in ……..
a) Local newspaper
b) Monthly magazines
c) Daily National Newspaper
7/28/2023 d) NotDPrequired to publish the notice
Bhatt, B Lekhak 68
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 34
Environment APEX 7/28/2023
Thank You
7/28/2023 D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 70
D P Bhatt, B Lekhak 35