docs(project-brain): promote the final V0.1 closure checkpoint (WO-024-P) - #98
Conversation
KayzenRoot
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
SOL AUDIT — CORRECTION REQUIRED at exact HEAD 103d1fe46c3ff589fb69854fd4626153c8487835.
The canonical promotion diff itself is bounded correctly to exactly docs/project-brain/13-CHECKPOINT.md and docs/project-brain/CANONICAL-SHA256SUMS.txt; PR is Ready, mergeable, and has zero unresolved threads. However CI run 35234129663 failed Validate: backend result 703 passed, 2 failed; Integration health and Review Evidence were skipped. Both failures are in backend/tests/test_v01_closure_sprint.py and are caused by tests assuming the repository checkpoint is always the pre-promotion state even when validating the promoted candidate. Under HIVE-ADR-019, merge is prohibited while any required gate is failed/missing.
Do not modify the WO-024-P two-file scope to hide this. The next authorized work must be a separate, bounded governance/test-only correction that makes those two regressions state-independent while preserving fail-closed semantics. After that correction is merged and post-merge validated, refresh PR #98 onto the new protected main, update its authorized-base marker, preserve exactly the two canonical changed files, rerun all three required gates, and return for exact-head Sol audit.
103d1fe to
71776ca
Compare
KayzenRoot
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
SOL FINAL-PROMOTION AUDIT
VERDICT: CORRECTION REQUIRED
Audited exact HEAD: 71776ca
Authorized base: 0df7bb1
Work order: WO-024-P
Hosted run: 35246912961
The canonical promotion candidate itself is correct and remains bounded to exactly two paths:
- docs/project-brain/13-CHECKPOINT.md
- docs/project-brain/CANONICAL-SHA256SUMS.txt
PR is Ready, mergeable, zero unresolved threads. Validate PASS and Integration health PASS. Merge is prohibited because Review Evidence FAILED on the exact HEAD.
Failure root cause is in the governance handoff, not the checkpoint/product:
- integration_evidence() intentionally does NOT emit v01_closure_sprint into the schema-bound manifest. This is protected by test_wo024_manifest_stays_schema_valid_without_closure_property().
- build_manifest() nevertheless calls fetch_wo024_approved_lineage(repository, integration.get("v01_closure_sprint", {})).
- Therefore the lineage verifier receives {}, and verify_wo024_approved_lineage() crashes when converting closure.get("dod_pass_count") / dod_total_count from None.
- The actual v01-closure-sprint-v1 artifact in this same run is present and PASS with DoD 46/46. The failure is only the wrong data source seam.
Required correction: create a separate bounded governance/test-only corrective increment WO-024-P-G1-C3. Do NOT expand PR #98. Keep the closure family out of the schema-bound integration manifest. Make the WO-024-P lineage path consume the already validated closure_sprint_evidence() (or an equivalent explicit validated closure payload) instead of integration.get("v01_closure_sprint", {}). Preserve fail-closed validation and all immutable lineage checks.
Required regression: behavioral, not source-inspection-only. It must prove that the final-promotion Review Evidence path supplies a complete closure payload with dod_pass_count/dod_total_count to the lineage verifier while integration_evidence() continues to omit v01_closure_sprint from the manifest. Add a negative proving missing/incomplete closure still fails closed.
No product code, no Project Brain/canonical files, no migrations, dependencies, workflows, ruleset or release changes. Do not merge PR #98. After C3 is merged and post-merge CI passes, refresh this same PR #98 onto the new main and rerun all three required gates.
STOP CONDITION for C3: exact-head Validate + Integration health + Review Evidence PASS, bounded corrective scope, auto-merge UNARMED, no merge by executor.
71776ca to
e407258
Compare
KayzenRoot
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
SOL AUDIT — CORRECTION REQUIRED
Exact audited HEAD: e407258
Base: 3eeb292
Hosted run: 35262112726
Promotion candidate itself is bounded and correct: exactly 2 canonical files, Ready, mergeable, zero unresolved threads, auto-merge unarmed, Validate PASS and Integration health PASS. The Review Evidence gate fails in governance wiring, not in the product/checkpoint semantics.
Exact failure:
ValueError: WO-024-P requires exactly one authorized-base marker
Root cause: build_manifest() correctly parses authorized_base_sha from the PR body, but verify_wo024p_governance_contract() calls require_wo024p_scope() without forwarding that parsed authorized_base_sha. require_wo024p_scope() therefore receives its default None while enforce_authorized_base=True and fails even though the PR body contains exactly one valid marker matching the base.
Do not modify the 2-file WO-024-P promotion to work around this. Fix the governance/test seam in a separate bounded corrective increment, then merge/post-merge validate that correction, refresh this same PR #98 onto the resulting main, and rerun all three required gates on one exact HEAD. Under HIVE-ADR-019, merge of #98 remains prohibited while Review Evidence is red.
…4-P) Refreshed onto protected main a84ac28 after the WO-024-P-G1-C4 authorized-base propagation correction merged, so the final promotion is a single commit descending directly from main. Exactly two files change. - STATUS becomes HIVE V0.1 COMPLETE / CLOSURE SPRINT APPROVED. - PENDING is emptied under the strict promotion grammar; IN PROGRESS, BLOCKERS and NEXT STEP take the exact promoted semantics the contract defines. - The historical COMPLETED prefix is preserved byte-for-byte and the eight canonical WO-024-P completion bullets are appended, generated by wo024p_completion_bullets() from the merged v01-closure-sprint-v1 evidence (DoD 46/46, remaining HIGH/CRITICAL 0/0, migration head 0007_telemetry_events) and from the approved product lineage resolved through the validated closure source (PR #95, audited head 649e7f9, Sol review 5233591627, squash 05d1425, post-merge CI 35204484706, backend 676 / dashboard 34). - CANONICAL-SHA256SUMS.txt changes only the 13-CHECKPOINT.md digest, re-derived from the exact candidate bytes; ordering, comments, line count and every other digest are unchanged. The complete WO-024-P governance contract passes on these bytes: promotion_scope, checkpoint_semantics, manifest_contract, closure_evidence and approved_lineage all PASS. No merge, no tag, no release.
e407258 to
1e480a8
Compare
HIVE Review Evidence — WO-024-P
Sol Review State: AWAITING_SOL Workflow run: https://github.com/KayzenRoot/hive/actions/runs/35276475557 |
KayzenRoot
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
VERDICT: APPROVED
Exact audited HEAD: 1e480a8
Base / authorized base: a84ac28
This supersedes the prior CORRECTION REQUIRED verdict anchored to the obsolete pre-correction promotion candidate. The current candidate is a single commit directly atop protected main and changes exactly the two authorized canonical files. The WO-024-P governance contract passes end-to-end: promotion_scope=PASS, checkpoint_semantics=PASS, manifest_contract=PASS, closure_evidence=PASS, approved_lineage=PASS, dod_matrix=PASS. Immutable WO-024 product lineage remains PR #95 / audited head 649e7f9 / squash 05d1425 / post-merge CI 35204484706.
Hosted CI run 35276475557 is green on this exact HEAD: Validate PASS, Integration health PASS, Review Evidence PASS. Hosted validation proves canonical verifier PASS, secret scan PASS, lint/typecheck/build PASS, backend 724 passed and dashboard 34 passed. Zero unresolved review threads. Auto-merge is UNARMED. Ruleset 21934284 remains active, strict, squash-only and without bypass actors.
APPROVED for exact-head SQUASH under ADR-019.
Revisão do executor - WO-024-P (promoção canônica final da V0.1) - refresh pós-C4
1. Resumo
O mesmo PR #98 e a mesma branch foram reconstruídos sobre o main protegido atual
a84ac28fb8aa84e4ea9b9e0a7e5ebe312e8a2028(squash do corretivo WO-024-P-G1-C4, PR #104), semmerge de main na branch: a promoção final é um único commit descendendo diretamente do main,
com exatamente os dois arquivos canônicos. Com o C4 presente neste main, a propagação do marcador
authorized-baseestá corrigida e o contrato completo do WO-024-P passa ponta a ponta(
promotion_scope,checkpoint_semantics,manifest_contract,closure_evidenceeapproved_lineagetodos PASS) — os três gates hospedados estão verdes no mesmo HEAD exato.A narrativa obsoleta de bloqueios C3/C4 foi removida do corpo deste PR e substituída por evidência
corrente. Sem merge, sem tag, sem release, auto-merge UNARMED. HIVE V0.1 não foi declarada
completa: isso permanece reservado à auditoria Sol e ao SQUASH exato deste PR.
2. Arquivos alterados (exatamente dois)
Nenhum terceiro caminho. Nenhum teste, script, produto, workflow, migration, dependência, release
asset ou outro arquivo do Project Brain foi tocado.
3. Semântica final do checkpoint e digest canônico (re-derivados)
HIVE V0.1 COMPLETE / CLOSURE SPRINT APPROVED.- None. V0.1 closure is complete and promoted.None known after V0.1 closure approval and post-merge validation.Operate the approved V0.1 baseline and track the post-V0.1 backlog.prefixo histórico de COMPLETED mantido e os oito bullets canônicos de completion anexados,
gerados/validados pelo contrato existente (
wo024p_completion_bullets(...)) — nenhum textoalternativo inventado.
require_wo024p_checkpoint_semanticsPASS ·require_wo024p_manifest_contractPASS ·checkpoint_current()PASS sobre o candidato promovido.3475eb7164ba17a4e095578e8b101668faa3980586a16affe8787aea6ff27d10→f7b5ab74301796b67be1bc65971396d91e290017ad06a23762f43902e4b826ee. Ordem, comentários,contagem de linhas e todos os demais digests do manifesto permanecem inalterados.
4. Lineage imutável do produto e evidência de closure
Lineage do produto WO-024 preservada exatamente, sem reescrevê-la para C1/C2/C3/C4: PR #95 · base
autorizada
4fb0aa111bd5b0f526df85b1897618d8eca1c0e0· head auditado649e7f90fc4f2d4e3cbc17ca0f38d5f2c9dd46ad· Sol review5233591627· squash aprovado05d142511f849d002c4ec8558fe4f43dca3e788b(ancestral do main atual) · CI pós-merge35204484706· backend 676 / dashboard 34. O C4 é linhagem de governança e não substitui aidentidade do produto.
Evidência
v01-closure-sprint-v1: PASS,closure_candidate=True, DoD 46/46 (0 FAIL, 0UNKNOWN), remanescentes HIGH/CRITICAL 0/0, migração
0007_telemetry_events, vazamentossecret/filesystem-path/cross-project
0/0/0e chamadas core LLM/provider0/0.5. Validação local (no HEAD exato desta branch)
python scripts/verify_canonical_sources.pypython scripts/generate_maps.py --checkpython scripts/check_secrets.pypython -m pytest backend/tests/test_v01_closure_sprint.py -qpython -m pytest backend/tests/test_review_evidence.py -qpython -m ruff format --check/ruff check .python -m mypypython scripts/validate.py"validation": "PASS"promotion_scope/checkpoint_semantics/manifest_contract/closure_evidence/approved_lineage)6. Identidade
governance/wo024-p-final-canonical-promotion.a84ac28fb8aa84e4ea9b9e0a7e5ebe312e8a2028.1e480a815da16276a57fa85ee7c1eb9ef87adc41.a84ac28(main protegido) →1e480a8(promoção, commit único).HIVE-WORK-ORDER: WO-024-Pe umHIVE-AUTHORIZED-BASEigual à base do PR.7. Riscos pendentes
explicitamente não bloqueante; não foi implementada.
antes do merge, conforme ADR-019.
Update de checkpoint proposto: o próprio checkpoint final promovido já contido neste PR.
WO-024-P REFRESHED ON MAIN a84ac28 - AWAITING SOL AUDIT