Repository navigation
[css-multicol] column-gap <length-percentage> remove at-risk marker #3988
Description
In #1321 <length-percentage> was added to multicol and defined as at-risk.
For the sake of having column-gap be the same everywhere, and as it does appear that Firefox and Chrome have both implemented percentages for multicol column-gap, it seems as if we could remove the at-risk marker.
Activity
css-meeting-bot commentedon Jun 4, 2019
The CSS Working Group just discussed
Remove at-risk marker for percentages in column-gap, and agreed to the following:RESOLVED: remove at-risk percentages on column-gap (and add some tests)The full IRC log of that discussion
<fremy> Topic: Remove at-risk marker for percentages in column-gap<astearns> github: https://github.com//issues/3988
<fremy> rachelandrew______: there was a resolution before I joined the group to mark percentages in column-gap at risk
<fremy> rachelandrew______: but Firefox implemented it, and now the property applies on grid and flexbox as well
<fremy> rachelandrew______: so they asked if the at-risk could get removed
<fremy> astearns: do we have implementation report?
<fremy> rachelandrew______: yes
<fremy> astearns: does any other implementation want to get it removed?
<fremy> astearns: I assume not since we resolved to allow it?
<fremy> florian: yeah, I'd agree to remove because sometimes implementors are afraid to implement it
<fremy> AmeliaBR: yeah, at-risk should be redefined to be less scary
<fremy> florian: yeah, that's just the name though, the description is already encouraging implementation
<fremy> florian: it would be nice to change the name at the w3c level, but this hasn't happened anymore
<fremy> s/anymore/yet
<fremy> AmeliaBR: do we have tests to back this up?
<fremy> rachelandrew______: yes, and on top of that we have tests for grid as well, where it is implemented
<fremy> astearns: any objection to remove the at-risk commned?
<fremy> iank_: there is only one test, and that is a bit low
<fremy> iank_: we would need tests for intrinsic sizing etc
<fremy> iank_: but I'm ok to remove the at-risk
<fremy> astearns: resolved then
<fremy> RESOLVED: remove at-risk percentages on column-gap (and add some tests)