Repository navigation
Browsers do not accept stroke-linejoin 'miter-clip' or 'arcs' #592
Description
https://svgwg.org/svg2-draft/painting.html#LineJoin
Name: stroke-linejoin
Value: miter | miter-clip | round | bevel | arcs
Blink/Edge/Firefox/Safari accept three of these values, but reject 'miter-clip' and 'arcs'
Test page: https://jsfiddle.net/ericwilligers/d65zk84s/
Should these values be marked at risk for SVG 2.0?
Activity
SVG Painting: property parsing
SVG Painting: property parsing
SVG Painting: property parsing
SVG Painting: property parsing (#14114)
Bug 1508060 [wpt PR 14114] - SVG Painting: property parsing, a=testonly
Bug 1508060 [wpt PR 14114] - SVG Painting: property parsing, a=testonly
css-meeting-bot commentedon Dec 3, 2018
The SVG Working Group just discussed
At-risk status of new stroke-linejoin keywords, and agreed to the following:RESOLVED: Mark new stroke-linejoin keywords as at risk.The full IRC log of that discussion
<AmeliaBR> Topic: At-risk status of new stroke-linejoin keywords<AmeliaBR> github: https://github.com//issues/592
<AmeliaBR> Chris: These really do have to be at-risk. They are new features, and we have no browser implementations.
<AmeliaBR> Tav: There are implementations in Inkscape, using a modified version of Cairo. They are also recreated with our live path effects.
<AmeliaBR> Dirk: You said you implemented with Cairo?
<AmeliaBR> Tav: In a modified version. Not in the public library.
<AmeliaBR> ... we also have a similar thing in the path effects, which uses custom attributes that are then exported as standard SVG path. It's very popular among artists.
<AmeliaBR> Dirk: Any objections to marking at-risk?
<AmeliaBR> RESOLVED: Mark new stroke-linejoin keywords as at risk.
<AmeliaBR> Eric: Do we have any feedback from implementers? Is there any interest of implementing?
<AmeliaBR> Myles: Same issue as before. Not a lot of feedback from authors yet. I don't think there are technical obstacles.
<AmeliaBR> Chris: Again, I think we need more worked examples and education to get people excited about them.
dirkschulze commentedon Dec 4, 2018
@ericwilligers Could you publish the tests to web-platform-tests please?
ewilligers commentedon Dec 4, 2018
The parsing test shows which values browsers accept. Each browser passes 3 of the 5 tests, as they accept 3 of the 5 keywords.
I skipped the 2 unimplemented values in the computed values test. I can add them.
Bug 1508060 [wpt PR 14114] - SVG Painting: property parsing, a=testonly
Bug 1508060 [wpt PR 14114] - SVG Painting: property parsing, a=testonly
Bug 1508060 [wpt PR 14114] - SVG Painting: property parsing, a=testonly
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes
LibWeb: Parse stroke-{linejoin,miterlimit} attributes