Repository navigation
[css-multicol] Proposal to drop example XVII #1740
Description
The multicol CR includes example XVII:
If a tall image is moved to a column on the next page to find room for it, its natural column may be left empty. If so, the column is is still considered to have content for the purpose of deciding if the column rule should be drawn.
This is in the current ED as Example 20.
In July 2013 this comment was made,
Second, I am not entirely sure what is meant by "natural column" in Example XVII; it seems to be the column box of first row, with the second row being on next page. For sure, I would want to see a real example with code here.
"next page to find room for it" suggests that such example can only happen in paged media.
The suggestion was to remove the example, I've been unable to find a resolution or further detail on this and the example is still in the spec. Anyone with thoughts, please comment.
Activity
rachelandrew commentedon Nov 4, 2017
With regard to the examples in general, I'm intending to recreate these as SVG (#1087) as in some cases the HTML and CSS examples are not very clear as to intent, or break in odd ways.
css-meeting-bot commentedon Nov 7, 2017
The Working Group just discussed
Proposal to drop example XVII, and agreed to the following resolutions:RESOLVED: Remove example XVIIThe full IRC log of that discussion
<eae> Topic: Proposal to drop example XVII<eae> github issue: https://github.com//issues/1740
<eae> rachelandrew: Again, raised in 2013.
<eae> rachelandrew: This example was dropped for reasons mentioned in issue.
<eae> rachelandrew: No resolution.
<eae> rachelandrew: Perhaps needs a clearer example.
<eae> Rossen: OK. Any opinions?
<eae> "If a tall image is moved to a column on the next page to find room for it, its natural column may be left empty. If so, the column is is still considered to have content for the purpose of deciding if the column rule should be drawn."
<eae> RESOLVED: Remove example XVII
[css-multicol] Proposal to drop example XVII w3c/csswg-drafts#1740