buc.ci is a Fediverse instance that uses the ActivityPub protocol. In other words, users at this host can communicate with people that use software like Mastodon, Pleroma, Friendica, etc. all around the world.
This server runs the snac software and there is no automatic sign-up process.
My daughter is complaining about her computer science teacher. They are building circuits in Tinkercad now, and instead of explaining anything to the children, their teacher gives them prompts for #ChatGPT to do the tasks.
I have no words to describe my deepest concern about this kind of teaching.
Isn’t Ai just a cover for the compliance with Cybernetic Systems CS?
Suppose those are just designed to capture information so as to control stupid and intelligent agents. If not why finance the use of autonomous agents to hack others systems and build drones to replace the conventional weapons of war?
As built, designed and or owned proprietary software is distributed by data centres. No doubt some people believe they are very clever because they can convince the public intelligence can be artificial when CS is just mimicry used to control their decision making. It is very stupid to believe you know what intelligence is if Ai is just a con; an information grab by broligarchs to profit from the theft and destruction of resources including IP. Suppose intelligence is artificial if that means information can be processed to correct presuppositions by subsuming the values of it, replicate, interact and sublate it. Also Suppose it is artificial as it has no emotions or feelings because it cannot be self-conscious Seles not artificial. #Ai was only ever intended to be a cover for #CS designed to preserve and protect the antitrust and monopolistic control of information processing. Hence Ai as envisaged is compliance with the broligarchs non-sustainable programme of ecocide! It is the technological apex of the ultras death cult! #AiAgency #philosophy #Freedom #Ai #EndingThe4thReich #CS #CyberneticFascists #TheNerdsReich #AiCon #JustDesert #FakeAi #AiJustice #RobinHood #RealAi #Revolution #BroligarchsEnd #AiThesis #AiAntithesis
I gather they've finally taken this measure because of the preponderance AI-generated slop, but with any luck these other issues will improve too. The arXiv press release states “Review/survey articles or position papers submitted to arXiv without this documentation will be likely to be rejected and not appear on arXiv” so it does sound like they are acknowledging the other problems and intend to enforce their rules more strictly in the future.
"arXiv says it will no longer accept Computer Science papers that are still under review due to the wave of AI-generated ones it has received."
From https://infosec.exchange/users/josephcox/statuses/115486903712973154
What you're seeing here is that for most categories, there is a linear increase in the number of submissions to the category year-over-year up until the end of the data series in 2021. Computer science is dramatically different: its increase looks exponential, and it looks like its rate of increase may have accelerated circa 2017. The chart on the right, which is the same data shown proportional instead of as raw counts, suggests computer science might be "eating" mathematics starting around 2017.
2017 is around when generative AI papers started to appear in large quantities. There was a significant advance in machine learning published around 2018 but known before then that made deep learning significantly more effective. Tech companies were already pushing this technology. #OpenAI (the #GPT / #ChatGPT maker) was founded in 2015; GPT-2 was released in early 2019. arXiv's charts don't show this, but I suspect these factors play a role in the seeming phase shift in their CS submissions in 2017.
We don't know what 2022 and 2023 would look like on a chart like this but I expect the exponential increase will have continued and possibly accelerated.
In any case, this trend is extremely concerning. The exponential increase in number of submissions to what is supposed to be an academic pre-print service is not reasonable. There hasn't been an exponential increase in the number of computer scientists, nor in research funding, nor in research labs, nor in the output-per-person of each scientist. Furthermore, these new submissions threaten to completely swamp all other material: before long computer science submissions will dwarf those of all over fields combined; since this chart stops at 2021 they may have already! arXiv's graphs do not break down the CS submissions by subtopic, but I suspect they are in the machine learning/generative AI/LLM space and that submissions on these topics dwarf the other subdisciplines of computer science. Finally, to the extent that arXiv has quality controls in place for its archive, these can't possibly keep up with an exponentially-increasing rate of submissions. They will eventually fail if they haven't already (as I suggested in a previous post I think there are signs that their standards are slipping; perhaps that started circa 2017 and that's partly why the rate of submissions accelerated then?).
Diversity of ideas is important. Sticking with a research program long enough to see it through is also important. Changing up what you're working on every time Silicon Valley ejects a new artifact that gets news coverage endangers both of those values.
And holy hell is the monotony boring. Computer science is an interesting, sprawling field with a lot going on! Let's keep it that way!
I'm aware that over the last year or so I've been a critic of #LLM hype so I too am reacting to it. Lately I've been considering changing that up.