Showing posts with label Sanabria. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sanabria. Show all posts

Monday, March 31, 2014

The Hispanic Bellwether in Miami: Gonzalo Sanabria. By Geniusofdespair

Gonzalo Sanabria
No one knows more than Gonzalo that we aren't fans of this Republican Committeeman at Eye On Miami. But we find his tiff with Rick Scott (who looks like a ghost in the commercial I saw this morning) fracturing the campaign.

Gonzalo Sanabria quit his Miami Expressway Authority Board post, he said in protest. Probably he was just sick of doing it, but the protest part is what got my attention.  According to the Tampa Bay Times:

Gonzalo Sanabria, a longtime Miami-Dade Expressway Authority board member, announced Thursday he was resigning from his appointed post to protest the “disparaging and disrespectful” treatment of Mike Fernandez, the former co-finance chairman of Gov. Rick Scott’s campaign.

“Since he has been treated in such a disparaging and disrespectful manner by your [campaign] staff and ignored in his advice, it is obvious that there is a great deal of dysfunction and disconnection of which I want to have no part nor can I render my support any longer as you are governing from a weak and flawed platform,” Sanabria wrote in an email he sent to Scott’s staff.

More tellling, Sanabria wrote:

“The Hispanic Community of South Florida is a key component of this great State’s vibrant socio-political fabric and treating us as you have is a grave mistake as it pains me to tell you what you will find out to the chagrin of us loyal Republicans,” wrote Sanabria. “Good Luck Governor, I’m not a fan any longer.”

Does this mean he will vote for Crist? Does it mean he won't vote (that is likely as there is history of Sanabria not voting)? Republicans rarely air their dirty laundry in such a prominent way. I am enjoying it.

Anyway, this crack in the ranks of monied, Hispanic Republicans in the Governor's race is so satisfying to me. First Mike Fernandez now Sanabria, at least they get the disrespect by the young twits. It took Hispanic Republicans long enough but it is never too late. Come over to our side - Oh wait, I am a Republican. Go over to their side, after all Crist is only missing one letter to make him "holier than thou": "an H".

Another scenario we haven't considered, Gonzalo Sanabria is trying to suck up to Mike Fernandez so he can get on the 'A' list party circuit. Politics be damned.

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

MDX: Justifying the highway to abyss, or, unlocking wealth for a few ... by gimleteye

Eye On Miami hasn't been shy about disclosing the land speculators, the GOP campaign contributors set to benefit, and the mind-boggling fact that the same forces that plunged the economy into the worst housing crash since the Great Depression are, only a few years later, intent on doing exactly the same through the proposed expansion of State Road 836 into Southwest Miami-Dade.

Last week on NBC, Jeb Bush derided journalists probing for a frisson of competition in his relationship with Senator Marco Rubio as "crack cocaine". It was an odd choice of words.

There is an analogy with crack cocaine in Florida politics. It associates the addiction to political money with re-zoning land for suburban sprawl. It's where the dealers and the users interconnect, and the clearest place to view it is where the pressure to build more sprawl rises in distant wetlands, open space, and environmentally sensitive lands near the Everglades. In other words, exactly what the Miami-Dade expressway authority is reviewing.

We wrote about this project a year ago, when it first visibly surfaced ... although it has been on the drawing boards for many years.


Before diving into the details of the political crack cocaine addiction, it is worth a review.

The enormous wealth generated through Wall Street finance based on mortgage derivatives depends on volume: volume of mortgages for commercial and residential real estate development. The volume, in south Florida, depends on local legislatures acting to open farmland to platted subdivisions. There is considerable process involved in "shifting the goal posts" in order to misallocate risk; wetlands need to be downgraded and rezoned, open space needs to be committed to bank branches, gas stations, and car dealerships, malls need to be built to service new subdivisions with residents clamoring for cheap services.

When, at some distant point in the future, taxpayers are left scratching their heads -- how did our quality of life get wrecked? -- the addicts point to "process" and "public hearings" and all the accountrements of re-zoning, downgrading, and destroying that decorate the Growth Machine Christmas Tree like decorations carefully packed and re-used as the years unwind.

The mechanics also depend on the illusion of spreading  wealth and shifting, or ignoring, growth's true costs.

That's the underlying story of the $1 billion wastewater upgrade that is now resting on the backs of county taxpayers, as a result of decades of inaction -- stretching back to the early 1990's when a federal lawsuit forces Miami-Dade County and the EPA into a settlement agreement that the county proceeded to ignore.

Today, anything  that smacks of regulatory authority or environmental enforcement is dismissed as "government over-reaching or overstepping its boundaries". This is commonly attributed to Tea Party enthusiasms, but Jeb! Bush articulate the core principle much earlier than the so-called "revolution" we know, now, to have been orchestrated by billionaire polluters like the Koch Brothers. Jeb!, in his final inaugural address as Florida's governor in 2003, boldly averred: “There will be no greater tribute to our maturity as a society than if we can make these buildings around us empty of workers; as silent monuments to the time when government played a larger role than it deserved or could adequately fill."

The crack cocaine dealers need the policemen to vanish from observing their street corner transactions. The Growth Machine needs new markets, free from pesky citizen suits and rancid delay: free for land speculators,  cement manufacturers, roadway contractors, housing developers and real estate shills to pack local county boards and legislatures every time there is an effort to insert new zoning or new infrastructure to speed land development toward the Everglades. Boards like the MDX are in place, with characters culled from the Growth Machine, to dot the i's and cross the t's. 

"Nothing can stop it!" crowed former WCI chairman Al Hoffman, who was Jeb's! hand-picked leader for the Council of 100 -- the state's top business lobby group -- in 2003. A few years later, the company Hoffman founded -- (Hoffman was also Jeb's and Dubya's campaign finance chair) -- would dissolve in bankruptcy. The point: the mechanics of suburban sprawl and land development are not only still in place, they have become even more frictionless with the decapitation of the single state agency charged with growth management by Gov. Rick Scott, Jeb's! successor.

This is what is unfolding in the corner of Miami-Dade at the western boundary with a plan to extend the SR 836  into farmland purchased at the top of the real estate bubble primarily by top GOP campaign contributors allied with US Century Bank (on US Century, check our archive). It is a tried and true formula for wealth generation: use profits from real estate development to secure political patronage, then use political patronage to stack permitting authorities and local boards to speed the way for new taxpayer investments that will double, triple, quadruple the price of real estate, and -- if you are very very connected -- arrange for highway exits and entrances to be put right where you want them.

Last February, we wrote, "Ajamil Bermello: members of the Growth Machine nomenklatura": 

"Nomenklatura: a category of people within the Soviet Union and other Eastern bloc countries who held various key administrative positions in all sphere's of those countries' activity: government, industry, agriculture, education, engineering and infrastructure development.

In Miami-Dade (and Florida) there is a parallel nomenklatura. Some key members of our own domestic nomenklatura are on parade through the effort to extend the Dolphin Expressway south on the western edge of the county, directly threatening Everglades National Park and benefiting land speculators who purchased property in anticipation of the growth of suburban sprawl: they are also key members of the nomenklatura and include Rodney Barreto, Ramon Rasco, Ed Easton and Sergio Pino.



This week, the board of the Miami-Dade Expressway Authority (MDX) unanimously approved adding the extension of the SR 836. Nearly 200 people voiced opposition to the project. Although it is not a done deal, changes to state law and agencies under Gov. Rick Scott and the anti-environmental GOP Florida legislature are going to make it quite difficult for citizens to stop the expansion that will expose many thousands acres of farmland to development pressure.

The local engineering firm, Ajamil Bermello, has put its shoulder to this wheels of progress.

Ajamil Bermello's Tere Garcia is providing public relations support for the MDX board. In response to opponents, she wrote recently in the professional, neutral tone that masks the frenetic investments of political energy to plow more highway in service of sprawl: "The extension of SR 836 is envisioned as a multimodal facility, used also by express transit buses, that would address the existing transportation needs of a vast community of thousands of existing residents living in the southwestern areas of Miami-Dade County west of the Turnpike. There will be no recommendation on MDX's behalf to move the Urban Development Boundary Line. Any alternative to be identified as part of the study must be evaluated considering all environmental requirements, sound engineering practices, be financially feasible and enjoy the support of those served."

Bermello Ajamil is part of the nomenclature that Occupy Miami and the rest of the Occupy movement ought to study. It takes a village to raise a child and confident engineers to wreck the village.

Willy Bermello, a founding partner of the engineering firm, famously tooted the housing boom in the Miami Herald in May 2005 at just about the same time much of the land in question in the SR 836 expansion was being purchased by nomenklatura friends: "This bubble is not latex," he wrote, "but stainless steel." The Herald provided no opportunity for rebuttal, showing its publisher also knew his place.

The point is that the worst economy since the Great Depression have not thwarted, changed, or modified the goals of the nomenklatura in Miami-Dade in the slightest. Ms. Garcia notes that the initial planning for the extension of SR 836 began in 2007: indeed, all that shows is that the nomenklatura have been intent-- from the start-- to build sprawl to the edge of the Everglades just like Broward."

It is worth tracking back to EOM posts on the land ownership patterns around the SR 836 planned extension. The only news in the Miami Herald report, below, is that commuters, through tolls, have funded a $6.9 million study that will no doubt reach the conclusion that the highway extension is a great public benefit.

The only reason it hasn't rolled out faster is that the real estate downturn turned all the assets in land into big craters on bank balance sheets. Some of these banks, like US Century, have struggled to keep their doors open and to maintain at least the figment of equity. (We still haven't heard all the details of who, exactly, was able to keep mortgages for large land holdings without being required to pay interest or principal while others were shut down and taken over.)

While small, individual homeowners found themselves forced to ruin by the downturn, big and politically connected land owners were protected by the banks that could not afford to "mark-to-market" the loans and so left them alone, once it became clear that federal banking authorities would do nothing to set the record straight.

These are hidden stories that sometimes emerge on 60 Minutes but otherwise stay mostly out of sight.


Take a good look at the owners of the property bordering the proposed MDX Expressway. Interpretation, to come.


New expressway idea for Southwest Miami-Dade draws fire

Tuesday, May 05, 2009

Gonzalo Sanabria is now OFFICIALLY OUT! By Geniusofdespair

My God! Those County Commissioners have no shame! Really. It is just puke inducing. They did try to do an end-run a couple of minutes ago, at the County Commission Meeting, trying to do a re-vote on the MDX Board vote. It was sponsored by the Vile Natacha Seijas: MDX do-over vote. Angry words were spewed towards Sorenson by Commissioner Pepe Diaz. She mentioned some of the shenanigans going on which he took great offense to. Well, I reported on it May 4th, so I heard about the shenanigans too. The vote: Gimenez voted no on the re-vote (even though he originally voted for Gonzalo Sanabria) which killed the measure. The offending, sticking up for counting Pepe Diaz's late vote: Sally Heyman, Joe Martinez, Pepe Diaz, Vile Natacha Seijas, Bruno Barreiro. Against: Gimenez, Sorenson, Edmonson, Rolle, Moss, Jordan, Souto. Sosa is absent.

So Gonzalo Sanabria DID NOT GET BACK ON THE MDX BOARD. Al Maloof is in. Too bad Armando Gutierrez. It didn't work. This is baby stuff. "Do over" is what a kid wants.


Monday, May 04, 2009

MDX: Do Over? I don't think so. by Geniusofdespair

The County Commission's vote for members of the MDX Board left Gonzalo Sanabria out in the cold and Al Maloof took the spot by one vote. Sources tell me that Armando Gutierrez wanted Pepe Diaz, who was absent, to vote after the fact for Gonzalo to create a tie. I guess this would have then caused a re-vote with plenty of time to try to persuade Maloof supporters to change their vote, if that is what was planned.

I don't think this is going to come up Tuesday at the County Commission Meeting. It seems as though Gonzalo Sanabria's political capital is spent if he couldn't even make this Board appointment. Maritiza Gutierrez will have to chair the Board with Maloof.

It is interesting to note who did not vote for Maloof:

Barreiro, Martinez and Seijas. Gimenez and Heyman: What were you thinking? I guess Heyman had to vote for Gonzalo, he was her appointment to the Planning Advisory Board. This is not to say Maloof is a bargain. I put his lobbyist list after Robert Holland's below.

Some of you out there should run for these Boards. I shudder when I look at the choices, as many seem conflicted at best. However, if a good candidate was there the County Commissioners wouldn't put them on the Board. We are in this crappy loop where all the Boards are appointed by the County Commissioners so we can never get out of having a pile of lobbyists on our Boards (and lobbyist's spouses). Look at who Robert Holland, also on the MDX Board, Lobbies for (Maloof's list is below Holland's list):

FOUNTAINBLEAU LAKES, LLC 4/3/2009
NONE Open
BCC ENGINEERING , INC. 3/13/2009
ENGINEERING ISSUES Open
RAILWORKS CORPORATION 2/19/2009
NORTH TERMINAL DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM AUTOMATED PEOPLE MOVER SYSTEM-WAGE DETERMINATION Open
AMERICAN EARTH MOVERS INC 1/22/2009
CSBE CONTRACT Open
LARO SERVICE SYSTEMS INC 6/16/2008
CORPORAE ISSUES Open
SCHEIDT & BACHMANN USA, INC 4/16/2008
AUTOMATED FARE COLLECTION SYSTEM Open
PURYEAR, INC 12/18/2007
NONE Open
BEST USED TRUCKS OF MIAMI, INC 10/16/2007
NONE Open
WASTE SERVICES INC 10/16/2007
COUNTY CURBSIDE RECYCLING PROGRAM Open
MIDTOWN TOWING OF MIAMI 7/17/2007
NONE Open
ALL DAY RENT A CAR CORP 10/19/2006
RENTAL CAR FACILITY SPACE ALLOCATION Open
FAMILY AUTO RENT 10/19/2006
RENTAL CAR FACILITY SPACE ALLOCATION Open
GLOBAL RAC 10/19/2006
RENTAL CAR FACILITY SPACE ALLOCATION Open
SIBONEY AUTO RENTALS INC 10/19/2006
RENTAL CAR FACILITY SPACE ALLOCATION Open
CORNERSTONE GROUP 6/22/2006
DRI AMENDMENT Withdrawn
ODEBRECHT CONSTRUCTION INC 4/20/2006
NONE Open

MALOOF:

H&CR REALTY, LLC 2/9/2009
NONE Open
FABER COE & GREGG 8/27/2008
MARKETING & RETAIL REVENUE ENHANCEMENT PROGRAM Open
TWIN VISION 7/25/2008
NONE Open
BANKERS FINANCIAL 5/30/2008
NONE Open
EMPLOYMENT RESOURCES, INC 2/22/2008
DBE, TEAMING AND OTHER MATTERS Open
EYE FLY MIAMI (MIA) LLC 2/13/2008
ADVERTISING CONTRACTS Open
ACS STATE AND LOCAL SOLUTIONS, INC. 12/13/2007
RFP 8181-2/22 Open
SMI SECURITY MANAGEMENT 11/5/2007
NONE Open
CLEVER DEVICES INC 10/17/2007
INFORMATION & DATA TRACKING SYSTEMS Withdrawn
TOD ADVISORS LLC 9/12/2007
COMMUNITY & TRANSIT DEVELOPMENT Open
ALL CARE RESIDENTIAL TREATMENT PROGRAMS 5/29/2007
COMMUNITY & SOCIAL SERVICES PROGRAMS Open
GOVERNMENT CONSULTING LLC 5/18/2007
PUBLIC POLICY & SERVICES PLANNING Open
LEO A DALY- ARCHITECTS ENGINEERS 2/27/2007
AIRPORT & SEAPORT ENGINEERING Open
THE HASKELL COMPANY 1/9/2007
SEAPORT, ENGINEERING, HOMELAND SECURITY Open
JAMAICA TOURIST BOARD 8/1/2006
NONE Open
OPTIMA BUS CORPORATION 4/25/2006
RFP 407 AND ALL BUS PROCUREMENTS FOR MIAMI-DADE Open
RED FLEX TRAFFIC SYSTEMS 3/20/2006
TRAFFIC SAFETY, TECHNOLOGY, PUBLIC POLICY, LEGISLATION Open
DOZIER & DOZIER CONSTRUCTION 11/18/2005
NONE Withdrawn
CAFUSA INC 11/3/2005
RAIL CAR TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS Withdrawn
SUNSHINE 2000 CONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT, INC 10/13/2005
NONE Open
FABER MIA LLC 9/21/2005
RETAIL/POINT OF SALE PROGRAMS & OPERATIONS Open
GENOVESE, JOBLOVE & BATTISTA PA 9/1/2005
PROCUREMENT, BIDS, CONTRACTS Open
FORUM BENEFITS OF AMERICA 8/16/2005
EMPLOYEE BENEFITS, HEALTHCARE, DENTAL, PHARMACY Open
GOVERNMENT & BUSINESS CONSULTANTS 8/16/2005
PROCUREMENT, BIDS, PROPOSALS , NEGOTIATIONS Open
RISK MANAGEMENT SAFETY CONSULTANTS 8/16/2005
NONE Open
OPTIMA BUS CORPORATION 8/11/2005
NONE Open
GJB CONSULTING LLC 5/4/2005
PROCUREMENT, BIDS, RFP'S, PROJECT TEAM ASSEMBLY Open
ROSS & BARUZZINI ENGINEERS 12/1/2004
TRANSPORTATION FACILITIES/ ACCESS-CONTROL SYSTEMS Open
NESTOR TRAFFIC SYSTEMS INC 9/15/2004
TRAFFIC / TRANSPORTATION / PUBLIC SAFETY Withdrawn
CENTURIAN 7/16/2004
CUSTOMER SERVICE AUTOMATED INFORMATION RESPONSE Open
CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS 1/22/2004
NONE Open
PENN CORP 9/10/2003

GJB CONSULTING LLC 7/1/2003
Open
LAWSON & LAWSON INDUSTRIES 4/14/2003
PENSKE TRANSPORTATION/VEHICLE MAINTENANCE Open

Friday, May 01, 2009

Herald Editorial on Scary Growth Bill in Tallahassee. By Geniusofdespair

The Miami Herald is pretty much always on target on growth management with the exception of their non-support of Florida Hometown Democracy (if this bill goes through I am sure they would change and support it.) The Editorial, Unrestricted growth no solution to state's stagnant economy OUR OPINION: Flawed bill would weaken oversight of development is well worth a read.

Let me give you an example. The Herald discusses State oversight on DRI’s (mega developments) which I find incredibly important. They say:

“We believe that DRIs should never be exempt from state oversight. Local governments too often are dazzled by the tax-revenue potential of big subdivisions to consider the negative consequences that such unsustainable growth can bring. The state can act as a more-neutral judge in these cases.”

If we look at Coral Gables, for example, let’s imagine that Gonzalo Sanabria won a Coral Gables Commission seat. If a developer were able to secure a large enough parcel by buying up a square block (like Merrick Park was put together, using City owned land as well) I would guess that Gonzalo would be the first to champion the development just as the Herald described. So we would be forced to rely on good people in office, not always easy with our stupid electorate. At least with the State of Florida as a second tier, we have another layer of government to turn to for sanity when our elected officials are dazzled by the lure of increased tax dollars and the opportunity to return favors to their pals.

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Sanabria admits Urban Development Boundary votes hurt his campaign ... by gimleteye

Chalk one up for reality. Two weeks ago, Coral Gables voters delivered a resounding victory to the incumbent city commissioner Maria Anderson in part because they knew that her challenger, Gonzalo Sanabria, lead many votes as a member of the county planning board in support of bad applications by developers to move the Urban Development Boundary. The Herald reports:

"The former member of the Miami-Dade Planning Advisory Board said ''negative mailers'' about his votes to move the Urban Development Boundary and the fact that he never voted in municipal elections in the city probably hurt him."

Yes and yes. As housing values fail to recover and taxpayer burdens become clearer to voters, I hope that Urban Development Boundary will become the important litmus test it should have been for the past decade. That would be a refreshing change.

Posted on Tue, Apr. 21, 2009
Money alone doesn't decide Coral Gables commission races

BY ELAINE DE VALLE
edevalle@MiamiHerald.com

The campaign war chests of the two Coral Gables commission races were as different as the margins of victory last week for the incumbents.
Commissioner Ralph Cabrera -- who easily defeated newcomer Richard W. Martin II by a 3-1 margin in votes -- raised 50 times as much for his race, according to campaign finance reports turned in the Friday before the election.

Cabrera raised $80,610 and spent about three quarters of it on advertising. Four years ago, he raised $35,000 in three weeks before he learned he would have no challenger. Then he returned the money to the contributors who would take it back.

He gave the remaining $2,000 or $3,000 to Actors' Playhouse, the fire department's Explorers program and the Coral Gables War Memorial Youth Center board.

Cabrera said Tuesday that he likely would have about $4,000 or so to dissolve after all expenses and that this year he would give it to the National Multiple Sclerosis Society and the March of Dimes.

Martin raised just short of $1,645, including $50 checks from residents Natalie Brown and Richard Namon, an activist who ran unsuccessfully for mayor in 2007, and a $500 check from a Boca Raton couple in real estate.

He spent almost $1,085, including almost $400 in yard signs.

The big money race was between Commissioner Maria Anderson and her challenger, real estate investor/developer Gonzalo Sanabria, a member of the Miami-Dade Expressway Authority and former president of the Gables by the Sea Homeowners Association. Anderson raised just over $113,000 and spent most of that, about $92,600, according to the reports, dated April 9.

Her contributions include two $500 maximum gifts from colleague Commissioner Wayne Withers and his wife, Cindy, and a $500 check from DYL Development, which wants to build a controversial condo and retail project on Le Jeune Road near the high school.

Expenses from March 21 to last week include almost $10,000 on a poll, more than $3,100 for a phone bank, more than $3,600 to Stan Adkins for one of her last-minute mail pieces and more than $30,000 to Community Power Builders, the firm owned by her campaign manager Irene Secada, for consulting, printing, mailing postage and T-shirts.

Sanabria raised $160,510, but $100,000 was a loan the self-made millionaire made to himself.

While Anderson raised more than $26,000 in the final two weeks before the election, Sanabria raised $14,400, including at least $8,000 in maximum $500 contributions from Hammock Drive residents.

He spent $126,800 in total as of April 9, almost $75,000 of that since March 21.

The expenditures include $2,500 to Armando Gutierrez, his campaign manager, and almost $54,000 for advertising and marketing to Creative Ideas Advertising, a company owned by Gutierrez's wife.

Sanabria said Tuesday that he is proud of his showing.

''We only fell short 323 votes,'' Sanabria said. ``That's not too bad, considering that I was running against three members of the commission, considering I was running against all the special interest.''

The former member of the Miami-Dade Planning Advisory Board said ''negative mailers'' about his votes to move the Urban Development Boundary and the fact that he never voted in municipal elections in the city probably hurt him.

``There's a whole lot of people that would like me to run again.''



© 2009 Miami Herald Media Company. All Rights Reserved.
http://www.miamiherald.com

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Coral Gables election separated candidates like oil and water ... by gimleteye

There are a few things to think about, after Maria Anderson's solid victory in yesterday's municipal election in Coral Gables over Gonzolo Sanabria. Here they are, in no particular order:

Don't run for office if you've never voted in the municipality where you are running.

If you voted for moving the Urban Development Boundary, expect to pay a political price with voters.

George Volsky and Roxcy Bolton are disconnected from reality. They picked the wrong cudgel and voters didn't care to be beaten by them.

Voters are paying attention to blogs like Eyeonmiami.

If you campaign as a "green" candidate, you better be prepared to justify your claims with solid evidence.

If you are an incumbent who voters elected for civic and community activism, be careful trusting government bureaucrats who make themselves seem invincible with power and its privileges.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Praise the Lord! Coral Gables Election Results, Commissioner Maria Anderson Beat Gonzalo Sanabria. By Geniusofdespair


Well, I am glad this election is over. It was nasty but the best woman won. I was told that Anderson won by 10%. Armando Gutierrez was Gonzalo Sanabria's campaign manager. He is usually the king of absentee ballots. I guess it didn't work out this time.

I am very happy about this election. There was a 20% voter turnout. The developers, with nothing much else to do, figured they would get a foothold in Coral Gables, positioning themselves for when the economy turned around. This particular race didn't go as planned. Maybe we can all think up some busy work for these guys. May I suggest a community garden?

I am going to amuse myself now:

Monday, April 13, 2009

Eye on Miami Endorses Coral Gables Commissioner Maria Anderson. By Geniusofdespair

I discussed it with Gimleteye and we concur with the Miami Herald, we also strongly endorse Maria Anderson for Coral Gables Commission Group III. We have the Miami Herald Endorsement at the end of this post so we don’t have to repeat what has already been written about Ms. Anderson.

Unlike the Herald, we also strongly oppose Anderson’s opponent for this seat. Our reasons are painstakingly detailed in 20 posts on this blog. We started writing about our discontent with Developer Gonzalo Sanabria in 2007, 2 years before the race began. We believe that with his long tenure on planning and transportation boards, he has been instrumental in weaving the web of what is wrong in Miami Dade County. Our blog masthead says:

"We aim to break the chokehold of Miami's developers and lobbyists on local government and the public commons. We offer our forum to that end."

This is exactly what we are doing with this endorsement of Maria Anderson.

We hope that all the good citizens of Coral Gables will do the right thing and give Commissioner Anderson another 4 year. Go out and vote tomorrow and tell your friends in Coral Gables to vote. To see the Miami Herald endorsement hit "read more."


The Miami Herald recommends
For City Commission, Group III

Maria Anderson, 53, with two terms to her credit, is facing challenger Gonzalo Sanabria, 61, a real-estate developer. This race is turning ugly, with Mr. Sanabria sending out fliers that mischaracterize Ms. Anderson's record and hint at improprieties, using innuendo that is skimpy on facts.

Overall Ms. Anderson's record has been one of sound reasoning on votes, and actions to promote better service to residents. She is something of a policy wonk who does her homework and thinks through decisions before acting on them.

One of Mr. Sanabria's accusations against Ms. Anderson is that she is pro development. That's unfair to Ms. Anderson, considering Mr. Sanabria's record. When he served on Miami-Dade's Planning and Zoning Board, Mr. Sanabria, a former chairman of the Latin Builders Association, consistently voted in favor of moving the county's Urban Development Boundary to allow more development.

The choice in this race is as clear as in the Group II race. Ms. Anderson has earned a third term. She was a moving force behind the Coral Gables Charrette that eventually produced a rewrite of the city's zoning code, ordinances that better protect residential neighborhoods from commercial development and a vision plan for the revitalization of Miracle Mile. Since first elected to the commission in 2001, Ms. Anderson has been a strong proponent of fiscal conservatism. She pushed the city to build its reserves, which at that time were just $600,000. Today, the reserve fund is close to $10 million.

If reelected, Ms. Anderson would continue her fiscal oversight in these tight budget times, urge pension reform and seek ways the city can increase revenue without raising taxes or fees.

Wednesday, April 08, 2009

Gonzolo Sanabria wants to be elected commissioner in a municipality where he never cared enough to vote ... by gimleteye

News that Gonzalo Sanabria was running for Coral Gables City Commission summoned memories of meetings of the county planning advisory board where Sanabria served as the pro-development vote collector for many years. As a citizen who attended many Planning Advisory Board meetings having to do with the Urban Development Boundary, I had first-hand experience how votes are tallied by applicants for development long before citizens ever stand up to the microphone to state their point of view. (please click, 'read more')

The stock scripts--like Sanabria's-- are so familiar, base, and worked out beforehand; that even newspaper reporters wonder what the fuss is all about. Hasn't it all happened before? What's the big deal? Every point is vetted by land use lawyers cozy with planning board members who will vote like Sanabria to move the Urban Development Boundary, defaulting to positions that might be useful in subsequent court cases, etc. etc.

The vote on Florida City Commons for instance, outside the Urban Development Boundary, in 2003 is exactly to the point. In the Miami Herald, Sanabria--now candidate for Coral Gables City Commission--defended his vote saying, "The environmental protections were there."

Bull. The Hold The Line Campaign, coalescing more than 150 business, community, civic and environmental groups, formed exactly because environmental protections for wetlands outside the UDB are NOT there. In the case of Florida City Commons-- a Lennar development that died on the vine but would have put more than 6,000 homes in Biscayne Bay wetlands-- the scam included the county surrendering control of future permitting to Florida City, whose weak commitment to environmental rules doesn't need explanation, only a drive through the area.

The entire history of development in south Florida is riddled with massive development projects seeking ways around environmental laws and, mostly, succeeding. That's the logic that Sanabria represents.

Because of the backroom dealing, I assumed Sanabria was making an opportunistic run at the Coral Gables City Commission for reasons that are obscure. Since that time, news that Sanabria has never even voted in a Coral Gables municipal election bears out that point of view. Joe Rasco made a run at Coral Gables city manager. Reportedly, Sanabria is gathering support from interests who wanted Rasco, one of the county development insiders, in that position. For some unstated reason, Republican office holders in the state legislature are also mounting a campaign in Sanabria's defense despite the fact the election is non-partisan.

So what does Gonzolo Sanabria really want?

Insider politics in Miami-Dade are invisible to the public. The pushing and pulling for influence and power never makes it to the pages of the daily newspaper. (Jim Defede was the last journalist to consistently report out those politics and he did it, not for the Herald, but earlier for Miami New Times.)

You don't have to be clairvoyant to see that even in the most lackluster economy since the Depression, that the lobby for development--as represented by Sanabria and his campaign manager, Armando Guttierez --are always looking for an edge; always looking for compliant public officials willing to carry out their zoning and permitting requests. As a former chair of the Latin Builders Association, Sanabria certainly was a full participant in the winding of the inner clockspring of government.

Most people wouldn't think much of failing to vote in a municipal election or blowing through a manatee protection zone (as Sanabria was apprehended, doing); but when that person is running for a public office, the underlying motives of deserve to be clarified. Uniquely among Miami-Dade municipalities, Coral Gables has advanced zoning and planning codes that are more visionary and restrictive of insiders who use the rules (or not) to break the rules to generate incremental profit from what is originally permitted or allowed. They help elect candidates who will be faithful to the principle that governmental processes exist to be gummed up. It's not hard work and it is done all the time.

It is really too bad that well-meaning people have fallen for the clap trap, but there it is. Hopefully Coral Gables voters will have reasoned through what is at stake in next week's municipal election and understand that Sanabria, who never voted in a Coral Gables municipal election, should not be voted for, in this one.

Sunday, April 05, 2009

Plenty of News on Coral Gables Election Today in the Miami Herald. By Geniusofdespair

The white hot race in Coral Gables between incumbent Maria Anderson and Gonzalo Sanabria was reported on in: The Metro Section and a Neighbor's Article and, finally Letters to the Editor. In the second link, on page 2 it says:

"But Anderson's supporters paint Sanabria as a developer with special interests at heart and have sent mailer ads that say he has voted several times to move the Urban Development Boundary line.

So what, asks Sanabria...adding that Gables founder George Merrick was a founding member of the planning board. "He was a developer and his main thing was to expand roads, to expand development," Sanabria said.


George Merrick died in 1942. Everyone smoked cigarette's and routinely sprayed DDT in their homes in the 40's. You would be better served studying Ruben Askew (one of my best posts) who served as Florida's Governor between 1971-1979. That is when the need for growth management in Florida was acknowledged and the concept of a master plan started to take shape. We got smarter as time went by...well most of us.

You just don't get it Gonzalo Sanabria, and you never will.

Saturday, April 04, 2009

Miami Herald Says "NO" to Gonzalo Sanabria and Endorses Maria Anderson. by Geniusofdespair

The Miami Herald endorsed Maria Anderson for Coral Gables Commissioner and says the choice is clear. They call her a "Policy Wonk." They didn't seem very happy with Gonzalo Sanabria:

"One of Mr. Sanabria's accusations against Ms. Anderson is that she is pro development. That's unfair to Ms. Anderson, considering Mr. Sanabria's record. When he served on Miami-Dade's Planning and Zoning Board, Mr. Sanabria, a former chairman of the Latin Builders Association, consistently voted in favor of moving the county's Urban Development Boundary to allow more development." And:

"This race is turning ugly, with Mr. Sanabria sending out fliers that mischaracterize Ms. Anderson's record and hint at improprieties, using innuendo that is skimpy on facts."

Thursday, April 02, 2009

Gonzolo Sanabria: the inconvenient truth ... by gimleteye

Gonzolo Sanabria is a candidate for Coral Gables City Commission in the upcoming April municipal election. There are many, many reasons for voters to vote against him.

Firstly, Sanabria was a loyalist in the battle to pump up the housing bubble in Miami-Dade County. He served as a former chairman and director of the Latin Builders Association, a director of the Greater Miami Chamber of Commerce, an appointee on the Miami Dade transportation agency, MDX, and for many years on the Miami-Dade Planning Advisory Board. In view of the costs of the economic crisis this status quo led us into, why would anyone vote for him? (please click, 'read more')

Although there were legions of insiders, like Sanabria, whose aggregate influence pushed common sense off the page during the housing boom; his role as a real estate speculator and developer promoting development on an important county board is a record that voters must understand: this is not a case where Sanabria can disavow claims to have had no role, or only a small one, or only as a by-stander to the economic disaster unfolding through unsustainable development.

The Planning Advisory Board for the county, where Sanabria was not only a reliable pro-growth vote but often a loud and insistent leader, is a crucial step on the way to county commission votes on development applications. As such, the Planning Advisory Board imposed massive risk on Miami-Dade citizens and taxpayers. There are any number of ways to describe that risk: risk to wetlands, risk to drinking water aquifers, risk to surrounding communities whose traffic patterns are immediately impacted by new developments, risks to the base cost of infrastructure that impose huge new burdens on taxpayers, and last but certainly not lease: the risk that overdevelopment would overwhelm demand.

This outcome does have a name and address: during the boom every construction and development interest in Miami-Dade was given a free pass to drive in the fast lane, or-- in a manner of speaking-- to blow through manatee protection zones.

When so many citizens attempted to express and convince decision-makers otherwise-- insiders like Gonzolo Sanabria had the final word. They believe, now, that they can say whatever they want to-- or ignore the inconvenient truth--, in part because there is a reasonable chance no one remembers or cares to look back at history.

In recently mailed campaign literature, Sanabria claims that he will "run (Coral Gables) as a business". But as the chairman of the Planning Advisory Board, he --repeatedly and often--failed to use sound fiscal prudence to decide whether or not to halt the reckless oversupply of housing and commercial real estate supply. The crowd in which he traveled included other builders, developers and speculators who believed, like former chairman of the Latin Builders, Willy Bermello, who wrote in the Herald in 2005, "This bubble is not latex. It is made of stainless steel".

Today Sanabria claims, in his campaign literature, that he will "take hold of uncontrolled growth". Yet he profited mightily from uncontrolled growth. On the Planning Advisory Board, Sanabria was frequently dismissive of development critics. It is beyond the pale to claim, as his campaign literature does, that he will "treat residents and taxpayers as shareholders."

How is that possible? In a recent report in the Tampa Tribune, a Sanabria development in Hillsborough County tried to bulldoze citizen opposition focused around traffic congestion. ("A Developer Drops Idea for Office and Retail Complex", Tampa Tribune, ) "Jordan Lewis, president of the Charleston Corners homeowners association said, "We're not opposing that the piece of property be developed. We just want the property to remain semipublic, keeping with the understanding that homeowners were presented with when we purchased our homes." ("Residents oppose the plan, and economics make profitability uncertain", St. Pete Times, )

In so far as his stated claim to "protect our green spaces"; it's all well and good when he voted to blow through protections afforded by the Urban Development Boundary just like blowing through a manatee protection zone. (07/10/2007, Judge Flora E. Seff. Gonzolo Sanabria).

Finally, what else is there to say about his claim: "Coral Gables needs an experienced and proven economist on the city commission" except to look at the past record leading to the present misery in the economy and recall the famous quip: “The only function of economists is to make astrologists look respectable.”

While on the Planning Advisory Board, Sanabria often resorted to the argument, in support of development requests, that environmental laws and regulations ensure that our wetlands, our shared water, and other natural resources are protected: the record proves how very wrong that record is. Read "Paving Paradise: Florida's vanishing wetlands": Sanabria should have read this book, before scattering his green signs over Coral Gables.

Those signs remind me of toothy beasts concealed in the clothing of lambs, of leopards painting over their spots, of people claiming environmental regulations work while blowing past them in no-speed zones. Beware.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Gonzalo Sanbria’s Campaign Manager Armando Gutierrez. By Geniusofdespair

Armando Guttierez is running the Coral Gables campaign of Gonzolo Sanabria, whose bad influence on the urban landscape of Miami Dade we have documented. Guttierez has a long history of waging extreme, negative campaigns and he is following that script according to Sanabria's direction against Maria Anderson, the incumbent. On the Sanabria mailer in Coral Gables, Guttierez wrote in Sanabria's name, "Our city is going through crucial times and facing many challenges. As your commissioner I am proudly determined to work hard to achieve the exemplary city we all yearn for." Sanabria is NOT commissioner!

Guttierez' wife, Maritiza serves with Sanabria on the board of the key agency charged with transportation in the county: the MDX. Highways are to development like sugar to a cafecito. Anyone who thinks that traffic and transportation in Miami Dade County are up to par and serve the public well, raise your hand and vote for Sanabria and Guttierez. Guttierez was a lobbyist for the Brown CDMP Amendment to move the Urban Development Boundary in the 2005 cycle, an application that Sanabria supported; another blow to residents of Kendall Drive and the massive transit nightmare that bad development decisions like Sanabria's helped to create. (Hit read more).

Maritza’s business works on campaign after campaign, her firm is called Creative Ideas Advertising. She also is President of Latino Public Radio. Maritiza estimated she was worth about $5,000,000 in 2007 and Gonzalo said he was worth over $17,000,000 in 2007 according to their most recent MDX Financial Disclosure Forms supplied by the State to an EOM reader. It would be an awful consequence of public anger if all it did was give an opening to the dark energy that made such a mess of our quality of life.

Friday, March 20, 2009

More on Steve Shiver and Ghost Town at Maggie Valley ... a guest contributor

Gimleteye writes: Steve Shiver is the former county manager of Miami-Dade, appointed by Mayor Alex Penelas to run one of the largest county budgets in the nation: at the time, over $6 billion. His only qualification: that he had done exactly as the Miami-Dade developers wanted; promoting growth at any cost including the ridiculously wasteful effort to convert the former Homestead Air Force Base to a private commercial airport for the purpose of cementing political insiders in place. (This is, BTW, the same mindset that guided Gonzalo Sanabria, candidate for Coral Gables City Commission, in his role at the county Planning Advisory Board. Please click, 'read more')
Shiver was, during his time as Mayor of Homestead, the prime instigator of irresponsible development leading directly to the oversupply and burdens on residents and taxpayers. Like a carpetbagger, he left Homestead once the housing boom he helped to push imploded and took his skills to North Carolina where he and other Miami developers took over a theme park that could also support the kinds of vacation home development so many wealthy and near-wealthy Miamians retreat to in the summer. We have tracked Shiver's story, because so many in Miami have an interest in how Maggie Valley works out.

The following is from a guest contributor:

"Why won’t anyone report the real truth about Ghost Town In The Sky? Steve Shiver is claiming that they have done major construction in order to get the park open again this year in spite of filing bankruptcy, However nothing has been done on top of the mountain and there is no more than 4 or 5 people left on payroll at this time. Why is a company filing for bankruptcy protection still doling out $10,000 Per month to its CEO.

Why has it not been reported that Ghost Town is saying that they have an investor that is willing to invest $100K for payroll and Operating expenses and more to come later (RESURECTION LLC) when indeed that investor leads back to Lynn Sylvester (Accountant and partner in GHOST TOWN).

If the company has money, why are they NOT paying any of their bills? $100K would go a long way in making some creditors happy. Why are these questions not being asked and reported?

Ask Mr. Shiver if he can guarantee that the roller coaster will be up and going? He will say “yes”, which would be a flat out LIE.
There is NO WAY that the coaster can be operating by opening. Check with the local State Inspectors and see what they have to say about it.

WE are all tired of seeing someone like Steve Shiver (with a history of bankrupting things) get away with FRAUD.

Check with Maggie Valley Water who has enormous outstanding bills on the park. If a park cannot pay for water (a basic necessity) how do you think they can open a theme park?

Ghost Town has tried to get the local motels to buy ticket packages to sale, although they will not offer to give them their money back if the park does not open.

More than one of the few remaining employees have gone in to have medical procedures done (assured by Ghost Town that their insurance was active) Only to find out AFTER the procedures that the insurance had been cancelled due to NON-PAYMENT. (What a surprise).

Someone needs to look into the background of Steve Shiver (CEO and President) and ask some real questions.

Don’t let another dirty politician get away with this. Tickets are still being sold and people are getting ripped off. If you ask the real questions. You will see that is is almost impossible for GHOST TOWN IN THE SKY to open for the season. It takes several weeks to put the rides back together and get the Grounds ready for park opening, However GT has no one working on these things as we speak. They are promising to open and taking people’s money. But are doing nothing to prepare for opening.

Please just give us the entire truth, some real reporting. I am sending this to several news papers and news stations so that maybe someone with some guts will do some real investigating and tell the whole truth."

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Gonzalo Sanabria: Self-Proclaimed Champion of The Environment, What a Laugh! By Geniusofdespair

I am not that offended when politicians make puffy claims on their campaign pieces. But this one takes the cake! I cannot believe that Gonzalo Sanabria claims he will protect the environment. Every environmentalist in Miami Dade County knows of his record on the Planning Advisory Board. Puleez! Now you are on my turf Gonzalo. A Sierra Club activist said:

"How many years did we wish for him to be removed from the Miami-Dade Planning Advisory Board...too many to count."

I find Gonzalo Sanabria's disingenuous claim: "Protect the Environment" offensive. Here are two better suited slogans for Gonzalo Sanabria and at least they are true: "I Support Rezoning Rights So Developers Can Go Wild" or "Smart Growth is For Stupid People, Not Me."

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Roxcy: Such a pretty name. Guest Blog by GablesWannabeNoMore

Roxcy Bolton and Vincent E. Damian’s Coral Gables Citizens PAC held a press conference at Coral Gables City Hall yesterday. It had to do with a recall of Mayor Slesnick because of the tawdry doings in Coral Gables. The press conference was not very reportable although all the TV stations were there (why?).

What I did find noteworthy was an exchange Feminist Roxcy Bolton had with another woman in the crowd. Apparently the woman was questioning Roxcy’s support of Gonzalo Sanabria. The woman told Roxcy that Gonzalo voted to move the Urban Development Boundary. Roxcy, no enemy of the Everglades, disputed that.

What exactly did Gonzalo tell Bolton? The truth? Perhaps she didn’t remember it correctly. We all know that in the 2005 Cycle Gonzalo Sanabria voted to move the Urban Development Boundary on 9 applications and, of course, there was Florida City Commons too which was outside the UDB line. And weren't there at least half a dozen in the 2003 cycle? I don't think Mr. Sanabria would have lied to her since it all can be documented. She probably forgot.

Unrelated: There comes a time when to retire is a blessing for everyone and, more important, a service to one's legacy.

Friday, March 13, 2009

Reject Gonzolo Sanabria, Coral Gables City Commission candidate gives voters a chance to hold architects of housing crash to account ... by gimleteye



As the economic crisis deepens, an unanswered question emerges: will voters reject the local architects of the housing market crash? In some cases we do know exactly who they are: the champions of growth-at-any cost who emerged in Miami Dade in the 1990's; like Gonzolo Sanabria who is running for city commission in Coral Gables in an April 14th election.

Behind Sanabria's green signs is a dark history as an operator for the building industry on appointed zoning councils where the public interest was steamrollered in the run up to the biggest collapse in housing market values in Miami history.

Sanabria's website glides past this era where it says, "... he served as Chairman of the Miami-Dade County Planning Advisory Board for five consecutive years." That's not all Sanabria did. There are some good reasons Sanabria would dumb down his record in this way.

Almost fifteen years ago, there were two litmus test issues on growth; one formed the community council process. The other was a measure fiercely opposed by the builders: the 2/3rds zoning ordinance. If a district commissioner had a significant concern about a specific zoning decision in his or her district, the ordinance provided that commissioner the opportunity to require a 2/3rd majority vote rather than a simple majority.

The building industry hated the measure and fiercely lobbied against it. So did Gonzolo Sanabria.

In 1995, the development lobby pulled out all the guns to stop the measure from passing. They called it a de facto moratorium on growth. The designator hitter for the industry? Gonzolo Sanabria.

"You are messing with economic chaos," said land consultant Gonzalo Sanabria, the chairman of the Metro-Dade Planning Advisory Board and a director of the Latin Builders Association," to The Miami Herald at the time. Read it again: according to Sanabria, the 2/3rds zoning ordinance should be rejected because it would harm builders and cause "economic chaos".

Look at the results of the unfettered building boom, that gave Wall Street the fuel to builds its own fires: that's the result of the architects of the housing asset bubble; Sanabria, included.

What the 2/3rds zoning ordinance represented was a higher bar for developers and a better than even chance for citizens who were advocating against the kind of unsustainable growth and its remnants, that now mar the county. Today's massive rate of foreclosures, the additional burdens on taxpayers, the economic crisis: these phenomenon did not spring from thin air. They can be traced back exactly to the development interests who wanted to pave over everything in sight. During the building boom, advocates like Sanabria got exactly what they wanted.

"The change in climate at County Hall already has been felt, (Sanabria) said. "It has had a chilling effect... It is pushing some builders to reconsider doing anything in Dade. Dade is looked on as an unfriendly atmosphere. And Broward is the winner." Sanabria and others say builders will drive their bulldozers north to Broward County if Metro-Dade places roadblocks in the path of development. Many builders -- including Lennar Homes, Weitzer Homes and Adrian Homes -- already straddle the county line." (Miami Herald, April 24, 1995)

The title of the Herald article: "The Death of Development in Dade? Builders Fear Metro's Moves to Slow Pace of New Projects". The fear-mongering that development would halt in Miami-Dade was lead by Sanabria, on behalf of his clients and associates in the sprawl industry.(The other designated hitter for the builders: MIguel De Grandy.)

The notion that the 2/3rds ordinance would kill development was just a plain, simple lie. Finally the measure passed.

The false arguments waged by the building industry in 1995, supported by Sanabria and others, were the prelude to the disasters of suburban sprawl that have resulted in today's tidal wave of financial misery.

Despite measures like the 2/3rds majority requirement and the formation of community councils, the influence peddling of the building industry steamrollered all civic opposition. During this time, mistakes by elected officials were being pursued with gusto: the private no-bid deal to redevelop the Homestead Air Force Base by a consortium of builders assembled from the board of directors of the Latin Builders Association at the time. Sanabria, on the Planning Advisory Board and various civic councils, was the HABDI guy. The 2/3rd zoning represented was a threat to development outside the UDB.

The same builders' lobby, who Sanabria represented during his time on the Planning Advisory Board, is STILL trying to move the Urban Development Boundary, despite more than 60,000 foreclosures scarring the built landscape. They will never stop.

There is no telling the tens of millions of taxpayer dollars wasted on HABDI, because Miami Dade County holds that information as a closely guarded state secret. It was, in the end, a fruitless effort that collapsed amidst litigation and violations of state law and intrusion on federal protections for our national parks. But Sanabria, when he had a chance to stand up for the public interest, was on the other side.

Although the public interest defeated the use of the former military base as a commercial airport benefiting Sanabria's supporters, the leap frog sprawl throughout the late 1990's and 2000's prevailed. We are living with the results and paying the price in spades. Again, this didn't happen by spontaneous generation.

On April 14th, Coral Gables voters have a chance to say to architects of the housing market collapse what they think.


Miami Herald, The (FL)
April 24, 1995
Section: BUSINESS
Edition: FINAL
Page: 24BM
Memo:COVER STORY; see box at end of text


THE DEATH OF DEVELOPMENT IN DADE? BUILDERS FEAR METRO'S MOVES TO SLOW PACE OF NEW PROJECTS
DON FINEFROCK Herald Business Writer

Has the welcome mat at County Hall been yanked away?

Dade County developers think so.

After years of allowing robust growth on the county's western fringes, Metro-Dade commissioners have taken steps to slow the pace of home construction in Dade.

Developers suddenly find themselves on the defensive.

In the last several months, the industry has suffered a stunning series of setbacks.

In January, for instance, commissioners unanimously rejected a proposed 320-home development in West Kendall because of school crowding.

The decision shocked builders, in part because it represented such an about-face by the Metro-Dade Commission. Last week, the builder whose project was spurned went to court, seeking to overturn the decision.

The real battle, however, is being waged over a change in the county zoning law adopted by commissioners earlier this month.

Developers say the change, if it stands, could halt development in unincorporated portions of the county. They call it a moratorium.

Nonsense, supporters say.

"Moratorium is one of those inflammatory words," said Commissioner Miguel Diaz de la Portilla. "Members of the building industry are throwing it around as a scare tactic."

At a news conference last week, Diaz de la Portilla said plenty of land is available for development. Statistics compiled by the Metro Planning Department and Price Waterhouse in Miami appear to bear that out.

Dade builders now hold a two-year supply of single-family lots, according to a market survey by Price Waterhouse in Miami.

Diaz de la Portilla said the point of the new law is to manage growth, not stop it, while giving residents a bigger voice in the process.

For too long, developers have had the upper hand, the commissioner said.

"The County Commission was like one big Burger King -- have it your way," Diaz de la Portilla said. "The fact is we have had a lot of problems that have been the result of unfettered, uncontrolled growth."

The law, adopted April 4 by a vote of 6-5, gives commissioners more control over development. A single commissioner can insist that zoning changes in his or her district be approved by a two-thirds vote instead of a simple majority, under certain circumstances.

To do that, a commissioner must present "substantial competent evidence" that the change would place an unreasonable burden on schools, roads or parks.

"Certainly a step in the right direction," said lawyer Jose Rojas, a former president of the Kendall Federation of Homeowners.

But builders fear the ordinance will be abused, and they have waged a fierce campaign -- on Spanish-language radio and at County Hall -- against it.

At stake, they say, are thousands of jobs.

An estimated 34,400 people are employed directly by the construction industry in Dade, and builders say thousands more -- bankers, real estate brokers, suppliers -- depend on construction for their livelihood.

"You are messing with economic chaos," said land consultant Gonzalo Sanabria, the chairman of the Metro-Dade Planning Advisory Board and a director of the Latin Builders

Association.

The change in climate at County Hall already has been felt, he said.

"It has had a chilling effect," Sanabria said. "It is pushing some builders to reconsider doing anything in Dade. Dade is looked on as an unfriendly atmosphere. And Broward is the winner."

Sanabria and others say builders will drive their bulldozers north to Broward County if Metro-Dade places roadblocks in the path of development. Many builders -- including Lennar Homes, Weitzer Homes and Adrian Homes -- already straddle the county line.

But proponents of change at County Hall, including Diaz de la Portilla and Commissioner Katy Sorenson, say builders are overstating their case.

"There is more supply there than the industry could possibly build for a number of years. That is why the issue of a moratorium is such a false issue," Diaz de la Portilla said. "It is a scare tactic, and it's not supported by fact."

A Planning Department survey of land available for development found space last year for about 119,000 more single- family homes -- or enough room to accommodate growth through the year 2010. Zoning is in place for about 70 percent of those units, planners found.

But builders and their representatives say those numbers don't accurately reflect supply. Some of the land may not be available for development, they say, while other parcels may lack all the required county approvals.

"Those are not adequate numbers to show what can be done," said lawyer Miguel De Grandy, a director of the Latin Builders Association. "What you have to look at is how many are ready to build."

According to Price Waterhouse, builders had an inventory of 8,336 vacant single-family lots at the end of 1994 -- roughly a two-year supply at the current pace of construction. The total rises to 9,822 if townhomes are included. About 4,079 of those lots are in West Kendall.

Builders broke ground on about 4,000 single-family homes in Dade last year, and they delivered 4,535 homes to buyers, Price Waterhouse reported.

Builders concede that the impact of the new law might not be felt immediately. But they say the dislocation will be severe and difficult to undo.

"If you shut off the pipeline, it takes another year to put it back in place," Sanabria said.

In recent months, much of the debate over new development has focused on the county's overburdened school system.

"What we are sick of is kids being put in classrooms where there are two classes in the same classroom, or kids being taught in closets or under stairwells," Rojas said. "That's what really aggravates the community."

When commissioners voted Jan. 12 to reject an application by Lucky Start to build 320 homes in West Kendall, they cited school overcrowding.

The project would have added an estimated 160 students to Oliver Hoover Elementary, Hammocks Middle and Sunset Senior High schools. Hammocks Middle and Sunset Senior are operating at 150 percent of their intended capacity.

Sorenson, one of seven commissioners who voted against the application, said the decision represented a watershed event in county politics.

"That's when I think things turned around for the better in Dade County," she said. "I think it was a signal to the whole community that we take the needs of children very seriously."

Lucky Start, the eighth most active home builder in Dade, contends that Metro acted improperly, despite the overcrowding. The builder sued in Dade Circuit Court last week to overturn the decision.

"Lucky Start's application could only be denied if there was competent and substantial evidence that the project would unduly burden government services," the lawsuit states. "There was no such evidence."

Lawyers for the builder argue that the project was improperly singled out as a test case, the first casualty of an "unannounced and extra-legal schools moratorium."

On a broader front, builders say they are being punished for a problem they didn't create and can't control: population growth. They fault the Dade School Board for failing to keep pace with that growth.

"If you want to keep people out, you don't shut the construction industry down," said Carlos Martinez of Caribe Construction, a director of the Latin Builders Association.

"It seems like that's the solution to everything now. Oh, we've got overcrowded schools. Let's shut construction down," he said. "Has it become crowded? Yes, the whole nation is growing. You can't stop growth."

But builders fear that neighborhood residents, armed with the new zoning ordinance, will try.

The result, they say, could be a "not-in-my-backyard" backlash against new projects and a de facto moratorium.

"Even if it's good housing that brings a lot of jobs and adds to the economic base, people will say, fine, do it somewhere else," said David Adler, president of the Builders Association of South Florida.

The new zoning law is likely to draw a legal challenge for just that reason. One possible argument: the two-thirds requirement for zoning changes violates due process.

"This is precisely the area where the merits are to be looked at the most, and the public sentiments are to impact the least," De Grandy said. "That is why the system works well when you have a majority requirement."

A lawsuit could be avoided if the two sides can compromise.

The Metro Commission opened the door to compromise last week when it took a first step toward defining what constitutes an "undue burden" under the law.

That change, proposed by Diaz de la Portilla, could placate builders, depending on what definition is ultimately approved.

A final vote on the change could come May 2.

Builders say the law needs to be changed in other ways, too, but as of last week, some believed compromise was still possible.

"There is room to address the legitimate concerns of both sides," De Grandy said. "The question is whether both sides will sit down and recognize that, beyond the political posturing, both sides have meritorious points of view."

FOR BIZ MON, page 26

Dade's top home-building companies for 1994, as ranked by
dollar volume:

1993 Dollar Average

Rank/Company rank Sales volume price

1. Lennar Corp. 1 664 $98,101,933 $147,744

2. Weitzer Organization 2 292 $33,331,500 $114,149

3. Heftler Organization 3 222 $30,739,356 $138,466

4. Shoma Development 7 143 $18,651,100 $130,427

5. Adrian Investment 4 143 $18,616,900 $125,992

6. Brighton Homes 8 145 $17,218,984 $118,752

7. Kendall Country Est. -- 81 $15,993,200 $197,447

8. Lucky Start -- 55 $14,319,700 $260,358

9. Caribe Construction -- 162 $14,307,500 $88,318

10. Landstar Homes 5 106 $14,115,900 $133,169

SOURCE: Appraisal and Real Estate Economics Associates.

cutlines

Herald file photo

FOR CHANGE IN ZONING LAW: Commissioner Miguel Diaz de la Portilla says the point is to manage growth, not stop it.


Illustration:color photo: Commissioner Miguel Diaz de la Portilla
(n); photo: David Adler (BUSINESS-A), Katy Sorenson (a);
chart: Top Dade Builders, Employment, single-family starts,
single family house closing, vacant platted lot inventory; map:
managing growth

Copyright (c) 1995 The Miami Herald

RSS| My Yahoo| Newsletters| Widgets| Mobile| Alerts| Twitter
About The Miami Herald| About the McClatchy Company| Terms of Use & Privacy Statement| Contact Us| Advertise
Partners: El Nuevo Herald| Newspaper in Education| WLRN | Miami Herald News| CBS4 WFOR-TV| More

Copyright Miami Herald Media Co. All rights reserved


Thursday, March 05, 2009

Coral Gables Candidate Gonzalo Sanabria Voted to Move the Urban Development Boundary Line Again and Again. By Geniusofdespair

On 11/14/05 Gonzalo Sanabria made a speech at the Planning Advisory Board meeting discounting Hold the Line (HTL). He said that Brown (one of the applications to move the Urban Development Boundary line) had 2,000 petitions and Gonzalo said that in comparison, HTL had the same 5, 6 or 7 people speaking all the time. He said maybe when HTL can come with 2,000 signatures we will listen to them. In fact, I don’t think Gonzalo ever knew, Coral Gables was a member of Hold the Line.

Communities joined HTL because with billions of dollars of unfunded and deteriorating infrastructure within the line, they did not want to further strain the budget by going outside the line. They wanted to catch up within the line first.

You would think while Gonzalo Sanabria was a member of the Planning Advisory Board, considering he lived and worked in Coral Gables, that he would have the interest of his hometown in his heart. He voted exactly opposite of Christi Sherouse (on every single vote to move the UDB Line). He voted to move the Urban Development Boundary, Christi voted not to. Heck, he didn't only vote he also argued in favor of most of the applications. He and Christi argued with each other during the preliminary meeting 11/14/05 and the final meeting on 3/30/06.

Christi Sherouse was representing the County Commissioner of Coral Gables: Gonzalo was representing the district including Aventura, Bal Harbor, Bay Harbor Islands, North Miami, North Miami Beach, Surfside, Sunny Isles and some of Miami Beach for Former County Commission Chair Gwen Margolis, then Sally Heyman. The Planning Advisory Board Members do not have to live in the district they represent. But, Gonzalo, you should note that North Miami, North Miami Beach, Surfside, Aventura, Miami Beach, Bal Harbor and Bay Harbor Islands were all members of Hold the Line. You were representing these cities on the Planning Advisory Board. You didn't even vote the same way as the Commissioner who you were representing. I think you agreed on one application: Hialeah. The rest, you voted to move the line and Sally Heyman voted no. Exactly who were your representing?

During the final vote 3/30/06, Gonzalo Sanabria voted in favor of every application to move the UDB line. He even argued in favor of the Doral West Commerce Park application in November, which was a half-hearted application at best, no one else was giving it much support. I think it might have been withdrawn but I am not sure.

Hey Gonzalo, if I heard you right, you argued that the Hialeah application would create 16,000 jobs. Have you checked on that lately? Follow-up is important. You also were voting for the Lowes Big Box Store application, you said based on the promise that they were going to sell the school board/charter school land for a new school. There was nothing in writing on that promise either. And, if the line was moved and the school board/charter school did not use the land, Lowe’s would have been free to use the land for other purposes. How do I know this? I sat in at the Administrative Hearings this year, Lowe's admitted as much.


It is dangerous to make such important votes on promises. Christi Sherouse didn’t vote like you did on any of the applications, she represented Coral Gables well. She listened, she held the line.

Monday, February 09, 2009

Gonzalo Sanabria's All-in-the-Family Endorsement. By Geniusofdespair

(Hit on images to enlarge them, and note the "delete box" is NOT checked in first image.)

Homeowners Associations rarely, if ever, endorse candidates. I was on 2 HOA's Boards and we encouraged residents to go out and vote, but we were told by our lawyers NOT to tell them who to vote for, it just wasn't a prudent thing to do. Not so in Coral Gables, the Gables by the Sea Homeowners Association not only endorsed, according to State records, the candidate was a member of the board that endorsed him until recently!

Actually, I was pretty surprised to see that a non-profit HOA had endorsed Gonzalo Sanabria, for obvious reasons - he is not the best candidate for the Coral Gables Commission for starters. Then I saw his wife Nancy was listed on their letterhead as a Board Member, that surprised me as they said the Board voted for him unanimously. Actually, Gonzalo Sanabria himself, was listed as a Board Member on their most recent Corporate Annual Report, filed in April 2008. Did he make a quick retreat after his 4 year stint on the Board, trading places with his wife to garner that HOA endorsement?

With his wife endorsing him, and his recent retreat from the Board, jokingly I will call this one: The Sanabria induced endorsement!