More Small Boats

I took Torpedoes & Tides to the club last night and played a couple of games against Daniel. 

We started with a basic fight scenario, with three British MGBs taking on a couple of larger and faster S-boats. I played the Germans and Daniel took the British. The night was moonless and most encounters were down to boats bumping into each other. This exchange of fire saw both boats lightly damaged.

More firing as other boats emerged from the darkness. Daniel kept scoring hits that suppressed rather than damaged the S-boats , but it meant that I was removing suppressions rather than shooting back.

Oh no! A couple of boats from both sides bumped into a minefield! Fortunately neither of them struck a mine and everyone studiously avoided that area for the rest of the game.

Boats studiously avoiding a minefield.

A long-range shot from one of Daniel's boats inflicted hits on one of mine. This was considered an outrage.

Meanwhile since my boats were constantly suppressed I was struggling to inflict hits back. 

One of Daniel's boats had been badly shot-up in those initial exchanges, and he opted to have it run for home. And one of teh S-boats decided it had had enough after its fellow fired a few shots at it by accident. This left one S-boat against two British boats.

The lone German put up a decent fight bit eventually its commander also decided that he'd had enough and he fled. So a win for teh British. 

No boats were lost by either side, although one British boat was crippled.

With time in hand we set up a convoy attack. Daniel took three S-boats against a British east coast convoy of three freighters, two launches and an armed trawler.

He struck out of a patch on mist on a moonless night.

Some blundering about in the dark by both sides saw a minor collision that damaged the lead British launch.

Daniel cut in between the convoy and the land, hiding his small boats against the coast. His first torpedo salvo missed.

The trawler opened up with its Big Gun giving Daniel a few scares. Owing to activation failures the trawler was pretty much doing all of the work for the British. It did manage a hit that knocked out a gun on one of the S-boats.

Daniel fired off more torpedoes and continued to miss. His boats sheered off so some of them might reload. At that point the trawler scored another hit, damaging an S-boat's engines.

All three S-boats were stalking one freighter now, but the British escorts were beginning to get their act together.

Not so the Germans, who managed a collision in the darkness that damaged one of their boats so badly that it sank!

Daniel's last salvo ...

... scored a hit!

With the escorts closing in Daniel decided not to pursue the other freighters and decided to head for home. The escorts tried to take on the S-boat with engine damage, but couldn't finish it off.

Despite their blundering this was very much a win for the British who got two freighters off their edge of the table and didn't lose a single escort. The Germans did get a freighter but at the cost of one boat sunk and another badly damaged.

Anyway, both games ran smoothly with lots of entertaining incidents, chaos and unpredictability.

Thanks to Daniel for an entertaining evening!

Some photos from Daniel

The Adventures Of Harvey Knight - 5

When dicing for Lt Cdr Harvey Knight's missions I seem to be beating the odds a little. His fifth mission was yet another convoy attack! Still, in terms of missions it's the one that offers the most in the way of reputation and glory, so no bad thing for Harvey.

With his flotilla now experienced Knight took four boats out, attacking a bigger convoy; four transports and three escorts. The boats were his own MTB 413, Stewart's MTB 414, Porter's MTB 418 and McDonald's MGB 103. Once again the MGB was used to spot the targets and provide fire support. 

Knight sent his vessels in on the centre again. The moon was over the land behind the convoy, so the targets would be silhouetted. He quickly spotted a freighter and, unable to line up an immediate torpedo run, took it under fire. 

Stewart in MTB 414 came up on his starboard and fired off his torpedoes, sinking the freighter. Seconds into the attack and the enemy had already lost a ship.

The Germans swung into action. A transport at the head of the convoy made a run for it, and Knight decided to let it go and focus on the two remaining targets. A Verpostenboot appeared out of the darkness, firing as it came. The next transport they spotted was a Siebel ferry. This would be a tougher proposition; its shallow draft made torpedo attacks next to impossible and, unlike the coasters, it was armed, albeit lightly.

Lt Porter took MTB 418 into an attack on the final transport, revealed as another freighter, but his torpedoes went wild. The other boats engaged the transports with gunfire, badly damaging the Siebel ferry. The German response was sluggish, with the two remaining escorts still trying to move up from the front of the convoy.

However the ferry and two of the escorts had Stewart's boat surrounded and under heavy fire. Somehow he took his little craft through it all unscathed.

Stewart and Porter hammered away at the freighter and the ferry, with both German vessels taking damage. The freighter was already belching smoke from a damaged engine, and more fire saw it slow to a halt, immobilised.

Knight's was the only MTB not to have fired torpedoes. He'd missed a clear shot at the freighter and, sensing that the British might need to escape now, decided to take a wild shot at the Verspostenboot. Against the odds he scored a hit and the escort went down!

McDonald's MGB had moved away from the action now, and headed for home, whilst the three MTB's poured gunfire into the stricken freighter. Try as they might they couldn't finish it off

A second Verpostenboot hove into view. And an R-boat was turning in to support it as well. 

Finally the freighter heeled over and began to sink. Knight ordered all boats to head for home.

The British boats now became uncoordinated in the darkness. Knight and Porter ran close inshore, looking to make their exit past the Siebel ferry on the hope that they could finish that off as well. But the second Verpostenboot, the Rahel, badly shot up Porter's MTB.

Stewart was running in the other direction. Both German escorts pursued him and he started taking hits as he struggled along the coastline. Things were beginning to look dangerous for the British. But eventually Stewart escaped to safety.

Knight's boat took ineffective fire from the ferry; last gasp of a finished vessel. Another burst of gunfire sunk it.

The final act in the action was a sad one. In the confusion and darkness, the panicked crew of MTB 418 mistook Knight's boat for a German escort and opened fire, seriously damaging it. They quickly realised their mistake and joined their commander in speeding for home.

The trip back to base passed without incident.

Knight's flotilla had sunk three transports and an escort, with his own boat accounting for two of them, and Porter and Stewart picking up a transport each. All four boats had suffered heavy damage, though, mostly from the end of the action where things got a little confused. In game terms what happened was that the first boat to act each turn had failed two activations, so for three turns the British were all but inactive, whilst the Germans hammered them with fire. The damage to Porter's boat had caused them to have to roll on the All At Sea table and fire on the nearest vessel; Knight's 

Results like that should have seen Knight's reputation increase considerably, but whilst he attracted some notice it wasn't the high praise he truly deserved. All of the crews involved had picked up valuable experience though; McDonald's crew may have made a limited contribution to the action, but they could finally be considered competent now, whilst Knight's boat were considered veterans. 

Knight did a careful debriefing of his crews and together they refined their tactics, something which would hopefully make them even more efficient in future missions. The repair yard did its best, but by the time of the next mission both Lt Porter and Lt Stewart's boats were still badly damaged, and unlikely to see action for a while.

The Adventures Of Harvey Knight - 4

Sometimes everything comes together as planned. Lt Cdr Knight's fourth mission as flotilla commander was just that!

Once again it was a simply convoy attack; three freighters with a light escort. With the moon over the coast Knight sent his three boats - his own MTB 413, Orion James' MTB 430 and Lennox Dean's MGB 91 - straight into the middle of the convoy. No fancy tactics; just straight at  them.

Quickly spotting two freighters, Knight's crew deftly torpedoed the first.

Lt James launched a difficult attack against the third freighter ...

... and sunk that.

Two freighters went down in one turn. The escorts - a KFK and two R-boats - fired a few shots and inflicted light damage, but were no real threat.

James and Dean sped away ...

... whilst Knight provided covering fire. There seemed to be no reason to go after the third freighter and risk tangling with the escorts.

The three British boats fled into the night, and home.

Two freighters sunk in one mission did a lot to enhance Knight's reputation, and gave the three boats involved some much needed experience. Indeed only Lt Ewan McDonald's MGB 103 was still a little green, and he would get a chance on the next mission.

The light damage was easily repaired and the only really fly in the ointment was Knight's inability to create much improvement in his flotilla's gunnery, despite him scheduling some special training. 

The Adventures Of Harvey Knight - 3

The previous post in this series had ended with Lt Cdr Knight and his crews having a celebratory drink. The next night they were off on another foray. And it was only as they approached the intercept point that Knight began to realise that the previous evening's beer was maybe reacting with the sleep medication he was taking; he definitely felt off colour and really not as alert as he should have been at this point in a mission.

Once again they flotilla was attacking a convoy and, once again, there were three boats attacking. With his own MTB-113 now repaired, Knight could lead his men properly. In addition he selected Lt James' MTB-430 and Lt Lennox Dean's MGB-91. This was the latter's first mission.

They attacked the convoy head on. With Knight not feeling his best the aim was to get in, do what damage they could and then get straight out.

Dean's MGB immediately took fire from a Kriegsfischkutter escort, but there was a freighter just beyond it.

The three British boats ran down the length of the convoy. They couldn't get a clear torpedo shot at he lead freighter, and contented themselves with lightly damaging it with gunfire. Two other escorts were revealed - another Kriegsfischkutter and an R-boat. Exchanges of fire saw a KFK lightly damaged but also Knight and Dean's boats.

The light damage was enough for Harvey, who decided enough was enough and signalled a return home. However Dean and James were still happy to try and inflict some damage on the Germans. James' MTB-430 launched a pair of torpedoes at the second freighter, and almost scored a hit. Almost.

A disaster for the Germans. In the confusion KFK 256 collided with a freighter and was sunk.

Dean and James both descended on the third freighter, guns blazing. They soon had it damaged.

But they couldn't inflict the final hits they needed to seriously damage or sink it, and heeding Knight's signals the three boats headed back into the darkness and turned for home

Two British boats were lightly damaged, and in return they'd inflicted a few hits on a couple of the freighters. Their biggest success was causing the confusion that saw a German escort sunk in a collision.

The three boats got home safely. The mission hadn't been a disaster but neither had it been much of a success. However it gave two crews much-needed experience - Lt Orion James' MTB-430 could now be considered competent - and the light damage they took meant that the repair yard could catch up a little. Only one boat - Ewan McDonald's MGB-103 - needed any attention now.

In fact Lt Cdr Knight, now recovered from his temporary inconvenience, spent a fair bit of his spare time with the repair crews, getting to know them and especially their commander, Lt Cdr Carter Reynolds. 

The flotilla was looking in good shape for their next mission.

In case you're not tracking things, after three missions (and a side-adventure) their kills are:

1 x Freighter (Torpedoed)
1 x Small Verpostenboot (Torpedoed)
1 x Kriegsfischkutter (Collision)