Rodgers and Hart's 'By Jupiter' Reconsidered

The final full-length collaboration of Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart was their longest-running Broadway success, yet very few recordings were made of its songs at the time - none by the cast - and almost no trace remains of the musical itself, save for a few numbers that are still heard today.

The show was 1942's By Jupiter, the pair's second foray into the land of the ancient Greeks (The Boys from Syracuse was its predecessor). The musical does not deserve its obscurity, as I hope this post will demonstrate via the few contemporary recordings that were produced and a 1967 LP derived from an off-Broadway revival.

Thanks to the ever-imaginative Dave Federman for suggesting this post to me. Like me, he is a great admirer of Larry Hart - and Dick Rodgers, of course.

The Story

Ray Bolger and Benay Venuta - he gave her plenty of nothin'

Hart's book for the show was based on Julian Thompson's 1924 Broadway play The Warrior's Husband. The title couple are Hippolyta, queen of the warrior Amazons, and her stay-at-home husband Sapiens - played in the original production by Benay Venuta and Ray Bolger.

Ronald Graham and Nanette Fabray

The other couple is Theseus, a leader of the Greek soldiers who have arrived on the scene, and Antiope, head of the Amazon warriors. In the first production, these were Ronald Graham and Constance Moore (later replaced by Nanette Fabray, as in the photo and in poster at top).

This is a simplistic description, but it's enough to get our bearings.

The 1967 Cast Recording

The most complete account of the score can be found in the cast recording of the 1967 off-Broadway revival, which ran for four months. In this production, Bob Dishy was Sapiens and Jackie Alloway was Hippolyta. Theseus and Antiope were played by Robert R. Kaye and Sheila Sullivan.

Critic Paul Kresh of HiFi-Stereo Review offered this critique: "Although Bob Dishy cannot hope to compete with the original performance by Ray Bolger in the 1940's as Sapiens, Hippolyta's non-hero husband, he is certainly winning enough. In addition, Jackie Alloway as Hippolyta, Sheila Sullivan as Antiope, and Robert R. Kaye as Theseus all have lovable ways and forthright, pleasant voices."

Bob Dishy, Jackie Alloway
Sheila Sullivan, Robert R. Kaye

The production - or at least this recording - utilized bare-bones orchestrations, presumably not Don Walker's original charts. The LP's sound was cramped; I've opened it out a bit.

The recording allows you to hear nine pieces not discussed below: "For Jupiter and Greece," "Ride Amazon Ride," "Life with Father," "In the Gateway of the Temple of Minerva," "Here's a Hand," "The Boy I Left Behind Me," "Bottoms Up," and the finales for both acts.

Next we'll discuss the principal songs; that is, the ones that were commercially recorded back in 1942, most of which have retained some currency today, however slight. They are "Jupiter Forbid," "Nobody's Heart," "Ev'rything I've Got," "Wait Till You See Her" and "Careless Rhapsody."

"Jupiter Forbid"

"Jupiter Forbid" is a rousing ensemble piece of a type that is or was a staple of musical comedy. The lyrics were inspired at least in part by patriotic sentiment in wartime America:

Maybe there's a place where people never laugh 

Maybe there's a place where kids don't kid

Maybe there's a place for just the upper half

Not here, Jupiter forbid

 

Maybe there's a place whеre people nеver sing

Where you have to hide each thing you did

Where they have a sign "Keep Off the Grass" in spring

Not here, Jupiter forbid

This is the second least known song in the group. It merited one recording in 1942, and only a few since - by Jackie and Roy, Andrea Marcovici and Peter Mintun (all not included in this set).

The 1942 recording was by Hildegarde, a popular cabaret performer of the time who sounds vaguely continental despite being from Milwaukee. It was one of four she sang for a Decca album of the time, which had backing by Harry Sosnik, also of the time. The other three songs are discussed below.

Hildegarde may not be not the first name that springs to mind when you think of rousing ensemble songs, but she does "Jupiter Forbid" very well.

"Nobody's Heart"

Lorenz Hart and Richard Rodgers at a By Jupiter rehearsal

In the musical, "Nobody's Heart" is a lovelorn lament by Antiope. The song is still heard in cabarets, few that they may be. It's perhaps most notable for how the lyrics and melody support one another. The words are unremarkable, although I have always admired this verse:

Nobody's arms belong to me

No arms feel strong to me

I admire the moon

As a moon

Just a moon

Nobody's heart belongs to me today

This is another song selected by Hildegarde for her set. She dispatches it smoothly. As far as I can tell, "Nobody's Heart" then went unrecorded until several singers took it up in the mid-1950s. For this collection, I've added the 1955 reading by Audrey Morris, recently the subject of a post here.

"Ev'rything I've Got"

"Ev'rything I've Got" is perhaps the most notable example of sex-role reversal in the score. Queen Hippolyta threatens hubby Sapiens in a manner that today might be considered macho:

I've a powerful anesthesia in my fist

And the perfect wrist to give your neck a twist

Hammerlock holds, I've mastered a few

But ev'rything I've got belongs to you

 Meanwhile, Sapiens has his own method, expressed in one of my favorite Hart stanzas:

Then at night we'll sleep and sleep

Sleep and sleep and sleep and sleep

Sleep and sleep, sleep and sleep

I'll give you plenty of nothin'

At the end of the musical, by the way, the sex roles revert to "normal".

"Ev'rything I've Got," perhaps surprisingly, was the most recorded song from the score in the early days. In addition to Hildegarde's performance, we have a version from the band of Freddy Martin - with a male singer bragging about the "powerful anasthesia" in his fist, which today sounds grotesque.

In the years since, it's mainly been performed by women, although the next recording would appear to be a Betty Garrett and Milton Berle duet from 1947 (you can listen to it here, assuming you can stand Uncle Miltie). Note that both Berle and Garrett sing the lines threatening violence; the "sleep and sleep" stanza is left out.

Hart wrote the song for Benay Venuta, who told the lyricist's biographer Frederick Nolan: "He [Hart] told me, 'I'll write a big number for you, babe, you'll stop the show with it.' And he did. He wrote 'Ev'rything I've Got' while we were in rehearsal, and it turned out to be one of the smash hits of the show."

"Wait Till You See Her"

In the play, "Wait Till You See Her" is a waltz declaring Theseus' love for Antiope. The song as written has a verse that is seldom used by singers today. It sets the warrior Theseus' infatuation in relief:

My friends who knew me

Never would know me

They'd look right through me

Above and below me

And ask, "Who's that man?

"Who is that man?

"That's not my lighthearted friend"

Meeting a girl was the start of the end

Love is a simple emotion a friend should comprehend

You can hear the verse in the 1967 cast album, which also uses a chorus effectively.

David Allyn

This song, somewhat familiar today, was ignored by the recording artists of 1942. The earliest version I've found was David Allyn's from 1949, which can be found in this post from a few years ago, and which I've also included in the present set of early recordings.

Also in that set is a relatively early (1952) instrumental version from Andre Kostelanetz. His recording treats the number as if it were a precursor to Rodgers' sweeping "Carousel Waltz" of 1945.

Frederick Nolan asserts that the song "was one of the prettiest waltzes Rodgers ever wrote, and Larry's lyric, with its unconventional rhyming scheme, had a lovely, matching tenderness. They all loved it, [director Joshua] Logan especially."

That said, there was some thought that it didn't fit the show. I've read both that it was dropped after opening night and that it was cut late in the run.

"Careless Rhapsody"

"Careless Rhapsody" is not a lost masterpiece, but it doesn't deserve its oblivion. The song, written as a duet for Antiope and Theseus, merited two recordings when the show opened, both solo. One, by Hildegarde, includes the opening verse. The second, by Clyde Rogers with Freddy Martin's band, does not do so.

The lyrics link music and love - heartstrings, etc. Nolan says Logan claimed that "Careless Rhapsody" doesn't sound like Hart's work at all. While it's not the best effort of the lyricist - or Rodgers - it's entirely pleasing.

To my knowledge the song has not been recorded since the show closed, except in a By Jupiter medley done by pianist Peter Mintun many years ago.

* * *

Why isn't the show better remembered? The simplest reason is that it is eclipsed by both the earlier Rodgers and Hart hits and the later Rodgers and Hammerstein blockbusters. It's about on the level of I Married an Angel, but not as remarkable as Babes in Arms, both of which have been discussed on this site.

Second, a Musicians Union recording ban began not long after the show opened, killing any additional recording plans that might have been contemplated.

Here's critic Paul Kresh's 1967 judgment of the show: "The score of By Jupiter is not as likely to stir your pulses as often as that of The Boys from Syracuse, but it has its moments, and the best of them are in the second act: the graceful, hummable 'Wait Till You See Her,' the casual 'Careless Rhapsody,' and the exuberant 'Ev'rything I've Got.' They don't make 'em like that any more. Not lately, anyhow." Still true nearly 60 years later.

LINK to 1967 cast recording

LINK to contemporary recordings