| Faye Dunaway in her infamous performance as Joan Crawford in "Mommie Dearest." |
“Only God may ever know what passed between
them. And in many ways, I think the relationship was the inevitable tragedy
that comes from a child of want, which is what Crawford was, and a child of
plenty, which is what the little blonde girl was.”—Faye Dunaway, on Joan &
Christina Crawford, Inside the Actors
Studio.
Contrary to film fans,
whether pro-Joan or pro-Christina, Joan Crawford was neither saint nor sinner. Joan, like many great stars, possessed even greater
contradictions. To say Crawford was ambitious, disciplined, and hard-working is
a massive understatement. Yet, the film icon possessed self-defeating behavior
that that eroded her reputation, even before Christina’s tell-all. Since Mommie Dearest, Christina has made a
cottage industry out of cashing in on trashing her mother’s name. Is it any
wonder that friends, family, fellow colleagues, and fans have so many differing
opinions about Joan Crawford?
| "Why must everything be a competition?" Constant mother & daughter dress-alike photo ops might have fostered that adversarial feeling. |
A favorite Tennessee
Williams line of mine is “the truth is at the bottom of a bottomless well.” Arguing
about who's telling the truth—Joan's defenders or Christina—may be
entertaining, but it is ultimately pointless. I think that Christina's
tales about Joan became ever more elevated over the decades, much like Tippi
Hedren's accusations against Alfred Hitchcock, and for the same reason: to fan the
media flames and to keep cashing in.
| One of the few behind the scenes shots on "Mommie Dearest," as Faye Dunaway's favorite catch-phrase apparently was, "Clear the set!" With director Frank Perry. |
Despite selling the
tell-all Mommie Dearest to Paramount
for a cool half million, Christina Crawford found out quickly how little
control she would have in making the movie version. For anyone who isn’t one of her fans!!!, you can blame Mommie
Dearest the book on Christina, but you can’t pin the movie’s script on
daughter dearest, as she had little say. Later, Christina aptly described Mommie Dearest as a Joan Crawford movie.
Mommie Dearest actually plays like a latter day Crawford movie, somewhere
between Queen Bee and Straitjacket!
| Don't remember this scene from "Mommie Dearest?" That's because this sympathetic scene between Joan & Christina was cut, which upset star Faye Dunaway. |
Some critics and
Crawford fans felt that Christina concocted Mommie
Dearest as a mashup from those final Joan Crawford vehicles. I think the
opposite is true. Hollywood often mimicked the lives of their most
flamboyant stars' lives for movie material. Especially those MGM divas:
Judy, Lana, Liz, and of course, Joan. Right from the start, MGM mirrored Joan Crawford's
hard luck life story as a huge part of her film persona. So why wouldn't later
movies, as Joan's behavior became more melodramatic and fraught, also become
film fodder? Crawford’s roles at this time correspond with aspects of Joan’s
professional and personal life in the ‘50s: Clean/control freak Harriet Craig; tough as nails star of Torch Song; the domestic dominatrix Queen Bee, half-crocked cougar in Female on the Beach, and the lonely lady
boss of The Best of Everything.
| Famed Joan Crawford photographer George Hurrell helped Faye Dunaway recreate some publicity stills for "Mommie Dearest." Faye had a striking resemblance to '30s Crawford. But Dunaway's fine-boned features were buried under '40s Crawford makeup for much of the film. |
| "Mommie Dearest" star Faye Dunaway with photographer George Hurrell. |
When you read stories
about the turbulent production of Mommie
Dearest, it seemed the emphasis then was on prestige drama, not camp
theatrics. When a movie starts with a problematic script and shortened
deadlines, then other elements spin out of control, it usually spells trouble.
For example, Faye Dunaway mucked around with wigs from one-time Crawford
hairdresser Peggy Shannon and costumes from Irene Sharaff. The designer was a
seven-time Oscar winner who came out of retirement to do this film, with
immediate regrets. Irene had worked with some major divas with quirks of their
own: Judy, Liz, and Barbra. Sharaff said that she had never worked with anyone
as unprofessional as Faye Dunaway.
| Seems Joan Crawford wasn't the only one with substance "issues." There's been much speculation about Faye Dunaway's "problem" on "Mommie Dearest," for starters. |
Over the years, nearly
everything I’ve read reports that Faye ran roughshod over everyone in the
making of Mommie Dearest. While Crawford had her
issues, Joan was smart enough to treat the people who matter, the crew,
director, the behind the scenes talent, etc. with the respect that they’re entitled to! At a gathering for
1976’s The Disappearance of Aimee,
Bette Davis nodded across the room at her co-star, Faye Dunaway, and told a
couple of guests, “Compared to that one,
Crawford was an angel.”
| This art work for "Mommie Dearest" is nearly as campy as the movie! |
As a film bio, Mommie Dearest is basically useless. The
’81 film fits somewhere in the middle of Hollywood's attitude toward film
facts. From The Jolson Story to Harlow, movie bios then were totally
fictionalized. Even the more modern era movie bios, like Gable and Lombard and W.C.
Fields and Me, were more visually accurate but still historically hogwash.
And during the Mommie Dearest era, TV
presented a rash of clichéd, sanitized bios of icons such as Grace Kelly,
Jackie Kennedy, and Rita Hayworth, to name just a few. Even modern celebrity
bios, like The Aviator or Feud, take questionable liberties.
For Mommie Dearest’s era, that there were even a few scenes with some truth was surprising: the “Christmas at the Crawfords” radio show is spot on; the opening scene with Joan Crawford’s day in a life as a movie star rings true; 60-plus Joan "filling in" for 20-something Christina on The Secret Storm makes the most sense. Also, the “tear down that bitch of a bearing wall” scene, as Joan lectures Tina on self-reliance and later berates Alfred Steele for his criticism of her spending, seems fairly factual.
| Faye as Joan subbing on "The Secret Storm" for her daughter in "Mommie Dearest." |
| The real Joan Crawford acting up a real "Storm!" |
The infamous set
pieces—the wire hanger/bathroom cleanser night raid, the rose garden meltdown, and
the home from Chadwick smack down—are among those open for debate. I don’t
doubt that regular physical punishment wasn’t a part of Crawford’s way of life
with children, but who truly knows about the more baroque incidents? But you’d
never know there was a happy childhood memory ever from watching Mommie
Dearest. Still, I have no trouble believing Joan Crawford as a petty tyrant
who rewarded and punished regarding gifts, clothes, thank you cards, and
manners, which have been commented on by those who knew Joan. For those who say
that’s the way life was, I realize it was a different era. But I can’t recall any
kid who had to “earn” their birthday and Christmas presents or was expected to
write hundreds of thank you cards, either.
| Seriously? What early teen doesn't love to do this? |
Despite Dunaway's occasional self-sabotage with the Crawford hair, makeup, and clothes, she blends her own voice with Joan's grand, MGM English and taut facial expressions, and ramrod straight posture. I saw Faye Dunaway when she toured in Master Class, playing another diva, Maria Callas. Again not ideally cast, yet Faye's incredible physical grace, posture, and demeanor were astounding. Steven Spielberg, who worked with Crawford at the end of her career, said while Joan was only 5'3", onscreen she looked six feet tall. Dunaway, who is 5'7", also looked larger than life as an actress.
| Aside from great legs & cheekbones, like Joan Crawford, Faye Dunaway is a STAR. |
In Dunaway's more in-depth
interviews, it's obvious she has great empathy and admiration for Crawford. Faye
seems quite sincere and moved by Joan's struggle, accomplishments, and problems.
For contrast, when Jessica Lange was interviewed for her Feud performance as Joan, Jessica said more than once that she
initially “knew absolutely nothing about Joan.” To which I call bullshit. Lange
was a struggling young actress when Mommie
Dearest came out, and also a classic movie fan—yet she knew nada about
Crawford? Feud tried to offer empathy
for Crawford's excesses, true enough. But it also played into the Mommie Dearest myth, and gave spin to
some further questionable gossip.
| Betty Barker. |
| Jessica Lange looks more like Joan Crawford's secretary, Betty Barker, than the star herself! |
At the time, Pauline
Kael was one of a handful of critics who gave Faye raves, describing her
performance as operatic. Ironically, when the acerbic Kael was lured out to
Hollywood by Paramount for a year, she suggested a young actress named Sigourney
Weaver for Joan Crawford. With her elegant voice and strong features, Weaver would
have been an ideal choice. And I felt the same about Weaver playing the older
Joan, decades later, in Feud, instead
of Ryan Murphy's pet muse, Jessica Lange.
| Faye's caricature as Joan syncs up well with Crawford's later looks. |
Faye's tendency for
caricature plays in her favor for Joan's middle and later years as the Pepsi
Queen. She's got Joan's ‘60s look down perfectly when she visits Tina as a
struggling actress. Dunaway is no dead ringer for Joan Crawford, but she does have
Joan's great cheek bones and legs. Faye finesses Joan far better than
Jessica Lange’s blowsy sad sack that was allegedly Joan Crawford in Feud.
| Joan Crawford, '60s style. |
| Faye got Joan's later look down pat... |
Faye has aptly
commented that she always relied on a strong director and Frank Perry wasn't
the man for the job. Dunaway's reputation on sets could be quite fraught, but
remember that she worked with great actors’ directors like Sidney Lumet in Network and Sydney Pollack in Three Days of the Condor, with no
fuss. Mommie Dearest started
with serious intentions, but when it went off the rails, in true Hollywood
style, the power players involved blamed each other. The film result was a
greatest hits version of Crawford's alleged misdeeds as a mother. As for Faye,
she took the brunt, as the star often does... remember Elizabeth Taylor's
drubbing as Cleopatra?
| The closest Rutanya Alda got to a requested photo with Faye Dunaway. Alda is long-suffering Carol Ann, a composite of several Crawford staff, in "Mommie Dearest." |
The acting in Mommie Dearest is as uneven as
everything else in this film: Rutanya Alda does her best as long-suffering
Carol Ann, and she has written about her frazzling work experience with Faye,
who wasn't exactly a team player. Mara Hobel as little Christina is a worthy acting
adversary for Dunaway. Yet, Diana Scarwid as adult Christina sounds so whiny
and twangy, that you wonder how far Joan travelled to adopt her—and why she
even brought her back! Jocelyn Brando has a nifty cameo as "Barbara
Bennett from Redbook!" She and
the scene are very sly as the puff piece writer who gets plenty of bonus material
from Joan at home.
| Mara Hobel as cool customer Christina. |
| Diana Scarwid as whiny adult Christina. |
Otherwise, the movie’s
short-hand for Hollywood types turns into caricatures: Howard de Silva as
Metro’s L.B. Mayer looks and acts like Ed Wynn; Steve Forrest looks great, but
is a cardboard cutout as "Uncle Greg," a bore compared to the real-life
rascal Greg Bautzer.
| "Uncle" Greg! Steven Forrest as fictionalized version of Greg Bautzer, showbiz lawyer. Forrest was also the brother of Dana Andrews, Joan's "Daisy Kenyon" co-star. |
What's to be taken
from Mommie Dearest 40 years later?
Not the totally true story of Joan and Christina Crawford, that’s for sure.
Those
who were close to Joan and claim that Crawford was never out of control include Betty Barker, the younger daughters, and
some of her most loyal friends. That absolute denial raises red flags to me.
There’s a long string of names I could list, of respectable and reliable show
biz folk who have seen Joan in action, in regards to bad behavior. But there
are just as many who can recall actions from Crawford that demonstrated her
deep and genuine need to be liked and loved.
| The last word? Hardly. Books, movies, and fans will argue about Joan VS Christina like they do about Marilyn Monroes's death, until end the end of time. |
Many books have been
written about Crawford, but they are just clip-and-paste jobs, with some “new”
gossip to goose sales. There has yet to be an authoritative, comprehensive, and
balanced Joan Crawford biography. This is a shame, since so many of her friends
and colleagues have passed on. In her day, Joan certainly issued the “official”
Crawford story for five decades. And Christina has certainly had her say for
the last five! Though the sympathy sword has cut both ways, from Christina’s back
to Joan’s side, now it’s time for the whole truth—somewhere in the middle, most
likely.
Faye Dunaway once
described Joan as “the great American movie star.” I will go even further. In her time, Joan
Crawford was the great American success story, played out on movie screens and
in print, for 50 years. Hers is a story worth telling, in its entirety.
| When will there be the great Joan Crawford biography or documentary? |
I have empathy for Joan
Crawford and Faye Dunaway, who both had difficulty later in their lives and careers.
Less acting offers and more gossip were
ills that plagued them both. Though Joan’s reputation was torpedoed by both the
book and film Mommie Dearest, interest
in Joan Crawford films never waned. Faye Dunaway’s stature was seriously
damaged by portraying Mommie Dearest,
and with her continual career kerfuffle, her current star power seems
low-wattage. Someday, perhaps Faye will be judged like Joan, just for her best
film work.
| Whether you loved or hated Faye Dunaway as Joan Crawford, nobody can say she just skated by on star quality as "Mommie Dearest." |
My take on Joan’s
journey to play Mildred Pierce: https://ricksrealreel.blogspot.com/2020/03/how-joan-crawford-became-mildred-pierce.html
My comparison of the
1962 memoirs of Joan Crawford & Bette Davis: https://ricksrealreel.blogspot.com/2017/02/bette-davis-and-joan-crawfords-1962.html
My take on the great
teaming of Joan Crawford & Bette Davis, in Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?: https://ricksrealreel.blogspot.com/2016/10/bette-and-joans-acting-duel-whatever.html
I’ve written posts
about Joan Crawford 17 times & counting!
Check out my blog: https://ricksrealreel.blogspot.com/
FYI: I put all the movie overflow on my public FB movie
page.
Check it out & join! https://www.facebook.com/groups/178488909366865/
| Even Christina's book has more happier moments with Joan Crawford than the movie "Mommie Dearest!" |