13 May 2019

The Great Doris Day

Doris Day was one of the great singers, but never received the respect she deserved.

A few reasons for this come to mind. First, she was very good looking, so was invited to make movies while still singing with Les Brown, and turned out to have so much talent, she became famous as a film star.

While she kept making records - and was remarkably prolific at it, at least for 25 years or so - the quality of her material was distinctly variable. Will Friedwald notes that she deferred to Mitch Miller and husband Marty Melcher in repertoire. Both wanted the hits to keep flowing, so the likes of "Rickety Rackety Rendezvous" ended up on the music stands.

Still, there was considerable depth of feeling in her singing from the beginning. It shows clearly in her first hit, "Sentimental Journey" with Les Brown. (I've uploaded a V-Disc version of the song on my other blog, in company with all her other V-Discs.) In his incredible book A Biographical Guide to the Great Jazz and Pop Singers, Will quotes singer Mary Cleere Haran as saying, "She's so sunny and bright, but she's different when she sings. She can be dark and mysterious, and there's a wistfulness and yearning in her voice." When allied to her excellent intonation and superb rhythm, you have the makings of a superior singer. And that she was.

When Day started making movies, the
endorsements came rolling in. From 1949.
Day was prolific, but virtually all of her output is in print. So as a tribute, I decided to bring you some more unusual stuff - the 21 songs she recorded for Standard Transcriptions in about 1952. These are relaxed, swinging and altogether wonderful. What wasn't so wonderful was the sound on the bootleg that compiled them many years ago. I acquired it when it came out, and was dismayed to discover sound that was considerably off-pitch with the tonal balance wildly awry. Back then, while I could adjust those characteristics, it was a hit-and-miss proposition. I wasn't too happy with the results.

Today, I took another crack at the source material, and the resulting sound picture is much more pleasing. The pitch is spot on and the frequency response is very reasonable. The sound is now good enough for you to enjoy an excellent set of current songs in the compact renditions that were normal for radio transcription companies. [UPDATE: reader Mac gently suggested that far from being "spot on," I had the pitch wrong on this set. After listening, I am sure he is right. I didn't compensate enough! There is a link in the comments to the repitched version.]

The first 10 tunes were done with the Page Cavanaugh Trio, a favorite of this blogger, which has appeared here several times. One of Page's specialties was accompanying singers, and he does well here. The rest of the numbers were backed by orchestra or combo, all quite adequate. But the star is Doris' singing, as always.

I've also remastered a five-year-old post of songs from her 1951 film On Moonlight Bay. The download includes a promo disc that has Day introducing four of the songs, and offering opening and closing remarks. (I do love promos.)

Finally, as mentioned, I posted her 12 V-Discs, recorded both with Les Brown and under her own name. This is a treasurable collection with several rarities. It's now on the singles blog.

After listening, I only hope you enjoy Doris' singing half as much as I do.



22 comments:

DonHo57 said...

Get to listen to this at the office today and enjoy. I had two crushes as a kid from about the time I was 6 - Doris, and Annette. Doris is the one who has seen me through throughout the years, and I guess I'll have a little Doris movie marathon this weekend in tribute. Thanks for some excellent music from a classy lady both on and off screen and record.

Buster said...

Hi Don,

You are very welcome!

Cast Annette aside, eh?

David Federman said...

A record producer friend of mine who was very close to Carmen McRae told me that she listed Doris as among her favorite singers. If that isn't praise, I don't know what is.

Buster said...

I love Carmen. One of favorite possessions is a autographed copy of her Blue Moon LP.

SwingKing said...

Thanks, Buster--a true treasure trove!

Ernie said...

Thanks Buster. Most everything of hers I've tried to listen to would fit under the heading of schmaltz, but I guess I need to listen again. I always thought she was great in the movies though.

Buster said...

Ernie - I have everything she ever recorded, and there is a LOT of schmaltz in it. You have to pick and choose. This is a good collection.

kiken said...

Thank you!

centuri said...

Unique Doris Day !
Thanks so much for this rare recording.

David Federman said...

Ernie, I take exception to your generalization of Doris Day's recorded output as "schmaltz." May I steer you to her "Day By Day" and "Day By Night," from 1956 and 1957. If these superlative albums change your outlook, I'm sure there are plenty of Day admirers here who will be willing to help you stay ON COURSE. Doris Day's loss is EQUIVALENT to that of Aretha Franklin's.

Mac said...

Thank you so much for this group kind sir, I'm curious how you know that something is off-pitch, the tonal imbalance I can understand but interested in how you arrive at pitch - it seems to me that some of these are in a lower pitch that I would associate with Doris - could just be me of course and I am thankful for the hard work you put into your posts - they are always informative and well done

Buster said...

Mainly by ear - I've known this was off-pitch since I acquired it 20 years ago. It was very flat. But it's entirely possible I don't have it right, so let me check! I'll repost if I can make improvements.

Buster said...

Mac - There's no question that you are right. I'll post a repitched version in a little while. Thanks so much for your note!

Buster said...

New link - repitched version (Apple lossless):

https://mega.nz/#!vI00DCab!UetkX-fmy5UvjCXsAeWiWprRA85iAlEUfcH6T6FuKow

Mac said...

Wow, you are dedicated to your craft and I for one greatly appreciate it - now I feel a bit guilty to be honest - something I'm sure I'll get over with the efforts here

Top Cabin Effort Sir

Buster said...

Thanks, Mac - and thanks for letting me know about the pitching fault!

jeronimo said...

Been a while since I visited your pages :)
Glad I decided to stop by today!

Thanks for this one Mister B.

j.

Buster said...

Hello jeronimo,

Thanks for stopping by!

Michael Bryant said...

Thanks for this. I love Doris Day.

Muff Diver said...

Thank you, Buster!

Dana Countryman said...

THANK YOU -- I love Doris during this period.

Buster said...

Hi Dana - please enjoy the recordings!