Original released on Double CD Really Useful 2724793
(UK 2010, March 9)
Better than I expected, though not as good as "Phantom of the Opera". Mr Lloyd Webber seems to have got some of his magic back. The style of this is much more 'Broadway' than operetta, but that suits the setting of the story, Coney Island, with its amusement park and side show freaks. There are passages with very prominent electric guitars which suit the tone and mood of the song they're used in but pull the listener out of the era in which the story is set. The cast are excellent vocally. The Phantom and Raoul and Christine and Meg Giry tend to sound a bit alike at times. The original Raoul, Steve Barton, has sadly passed away. (in RateYourMusic)

Few musicals have enjoyed the cultural (and financial) longevity of "The Phantom of the Opera". Lyricists Charles Hart and Richard Stilgoe, and composer Andre Lloyd Webber’s take on the classic French novel by author Gaston Leroux, opened in 1986 with no endgame in sight, which makes one wonder why it took so long to cash in and make a sequel. In 2010, Webber, along with writer Glenn Slater, who won a Tony for his work on the 2007 stage adaptation of the 1989 Disney film "The Little Mermaid", brought Christine Daaé and the Phantom together again in "Love Never Dies". Set ten years after the events of the first installment, the Phantom has lured his muse from Paris to New York City for a performance (that unbeknownst to her, he set up) at a new venue called Phantasma in Coney Island. High drama and tragedy ensue (fans of the original will revel in the gothic splendor of pieces like “The Coney Island Waltz” and the crafty/schmaltzy ballads “Til I Hear You Sing” and the beautiful “Love Never Dies”), allowing Webber to spin a predictable but effective new set of themes that both celebrate the half-masked anti-hero’s pipe organ past while allowing him to evolve (as much as he can with his anger issues and addiction to heartache) beneath the formidable shadows of the Big Apple. (James Christopher Monger in AllMusic)