Original Released on LP Island ILPS 9166 (1971/09)
SOME REVIEWS:How you react to this album will probably have more than a little to do with just how much of an original Traffic freak you are. And if you loved the Spencer Davis Group during its mid-Sixties coming-to-be, then you may also have your reservations. Oh, all the right personnel are on hand - Stevie Winwood, Jim Capaldi, Dave Mason and Chris Wood - but it's pretty hard to improve on perfection. So it sounds strangely hollow to hear these four, buttressed by the addition of Rick Grech (Family, Blind Faith), Kwaku Baah and Jim Gordon, serving up still another helping of "Medicated Goo," "40,000 Headmen," "Dear Mr. Fantasy" and "Gimme Some Lovin'." The whole thing was recorded at a live concert in Croydon and at the Oz Benefit Concert in London. Certainly the Oz fund could be considered a worthy cause, but since the profits from this record are going elsewhere, there's an element of rip-off to the proceedings. Still, if you're into nostalgia, or if you want to hear some fair to good live versions of what have already become rock classics, you might want to tune in on these tracks. But for the real thing, you still can't beat the originals!
(Circus, 1/72)
Former Traffic members get together for this live recording which shows off the tremendous instrumental and songwriting talents of the group. The band jams on a 14-minute "Dear Mr. Fantasy" and an extended version of the famous "Gimme Some Lovin'," Also included are Dave Mason songs, "Shouldn't Have Took More Than You Gave" and "Sad and Deep as You."
(Billboard, 1972)
Following the success of John Barleycorn Must Die, Traffic planned a concert album for the fall of 1970, and it got as far as a test pressing before being canceled. A recording was necessary to satisfy the terms of British label Island records' licensing deal with American label United Artists, which had provided for five albums, of which four had been delivered. With Island starting to release its own albums in the U.S., the UA contract had to be completed, and hopefully not with the potentially lucrative studio follow-up to John Barleycorn Must Die. Thus, Traffic tried again to come up with a live album by recording shows on a British tour in July 1971. Joining for six dates of the tour was twice-dismissed Traffic singer/guitarist Dave Mason, who had subsequently scored a solo success with his Alone Together album. The resulting collection, Welcome to the Canteen (which was technically credited to the seven individual musicians, not to Traffic), proved how good a contractual obligation album could be. Sound quality was not the best (and it still isn't on the 2002 remastered CD reissue, though it's better), with the vocals under-recorded and stray sounds honing in, but the playing was exemplary, and the set list was an excellent mixture of old Traffic songs and recent Mason favorites. Dear Mr. Fantasy got an extended workout, and the capper was a rearranged version of Steve Winwood's old Spencer Davis Group hit "Gimme Some Lovin'"
(All Music)
